The search for Celtic's next permanent manager has taken a controversial turn, with former club captain Scott Brown's candidacy being publicly questioned by ex-Rangers and Manchester City striker Gordon Dalziel.
Dalziel's Blunt Assessment
Speaking on Clyde 1 Superscoreboard, Dalziel did not hold back in his criticism of Brown's links to the vacant position. The 63-year-old pundit argued that Brown's legendary status as a player for the Scottish side is the sole reason he is being considered.
Gordon Dalziel told a caller that when big clubs like Celtic or Rangers have a vacancy, there is often a sentiment to "get a Celtic man in." However, he was adamant that this should not be the primary qualification for the role.
He posed a direct challenge to this line of thinking, asking: "Put it this way, saying Scott Brown had never played for Celtic. Would Scott Brown be able to get in and be a manager or coach at Celtic?" The implication was a clear no.
Experience Versus Pedigree
The debate intensified when another caller drew a parallel with the legendary Sir Alex Ferguson, who managed St Mirren and Aberdeen before his historic move to Manchester United. Dalziel was quick to highlight the crucial difference.
He pointed out that Sir Alex Ferguson won European trophies and leagues at Aberdeen before his Manchester United appointment. In stark contrast, Dalziel stated bluntly of Brown: "Scott Brown hasn't won anything."
Brown, who is the current manager of Ayr United, enjoyed a phenomenal playing career. He retired in 2022 after securing an incredible 22 major honours with Celtic. Despite this glittering playing history, his managerial resume is still in its early stages.
The Wider Managerial Hunt
Celtic have been searching for a permanent manager since Brendan Rodgers departed the club last month. This followed a disappointing start to the season with a string of poor results.
While Brown's name is in the mix, a surprise frontrunner has emerged in the form of French manager Wilfried Nancy. Nancy has garnered significant attention following his success with MLS side Columbus Crew, making him a serious contender for the role at Celtic Park.
The situation highlights the ongoing tension in football between appointing a club legend and seeking a proven manager with a track record of silverware. For now, the search for Celtic's next leader continues, with Dalziel's comments adding fuel to an already fiery debate.
