Manchester United legend Gary Neville has delivered a blunt verdict on the club's managerial situation, stating that interim boss Michael Carrick should not be considered for the permanent role at Old Trafford.
Neville's Firm Stance on Carrick's Future
Speaking on the Stick to Football podcast, Neville was unequivocal about his former teammate's prospects. Carrick was appointed as interim head coach on Tuesday 13 January 2026, following the sacking of Ruben Amorim and a brief caretaker spell under Darren Fletcher.
"I hope he does really well," Neville said of Carrick. "There cannot be any consideration that Michael takes the job beyond this season, for Michael and for the club." He acknowledged the possibility of a successful run but maintained his position, suggesting the club must look elsewhere this summer.
Keane's Demand for the 'Best of the Best'
Former captain Roy Keane echoed Neville's sentiments, urging United's hierarchy to be ambitious in their search. He cited high-profile managers like Diego Simeone of Atletico Madrid and Luis Enrique of Paris St Germain as the calibre of candidate the club should pursue.
When Neville questioned the realism of landing such names, Keane retorted: "But isn't that bizarre, we're talking about options and you're ruling people out. United should be thinking 'let's try and get the best of the best'."
Keane also emphasised the unique mentality required to succeed at United, stating that players and staff must embrace the immense pressure and expectation that comes with the role.
The Search for a Long-Term Leader
Neville specifically highlighted the availability of world-class managers, naming Mauricio Pochettino, Thomas Tuchel, and Carlo Ancelotti. He pointed to Ancelotti's age, current role, and vast Premier League experience as particularly appealing attributes.
The club's decision to install Carrick, the former Middlesbrough manager, on a short-term basis is understood to be a strategic move. It allows director of football Jason Wilcox to lead a thorough and unhurried recruitment process over the coming months.
The club's co-owners, Sir Jim Ratcliffe, Joel Glazer, and Avram Glazer, were reportedly at Carrington on Thursday, showing support for Carrick ahead of his first match in charge—a crucial Premier League clash against Manchester City on Saturday.
As the club navigates a pivotal period in its history, the message from two of its most iconic figures is clear: sentiment must be set aside in the pursuit of elite, proven leadership to restore Manchester United to the summit of English and European football.
