Manchester United Player Ratings: Shocking Performances in Liverpool Demolition at Old Trafford
Man Utd player ratings: Liverpool humiliation analysed

Manchester United's season plunged to new depths as Liverpool delivered a devastating 4-2 defeat at Old Trafford, exposing the gulf in quality between these historic rivals.

Defensive Disarray at the Theatre of Dreams

The United backline crumbled under relentless Liverpool pressure, with individual errors proving costly throughout the match. From the opening whistle, the home side looked vulnerable, unable to cope with Liverpool's attacking fluidity and intensity.

André Onana endured another difficult afternoon between the sticks, his distribution erratic and positioning questionable for several of Liverpool's goals. The Cameroonian goalkeeper appears to be suffering from a crisis of confidence that's spreading throughout the defence.

Midfield Mismatch Proves Decisive

United's engine room was completely overrun, with Liverpool dominating possession and controlling the tempo. The absence of any cohesive pressing strategy left gaping holes that Liverpool's creative players exploited at will.

While Bruno Fernandes managed to get on the scoresheet, his overall performance reflected United's disjointed approach. The Portuguese captain struggled to influence the game positively, often dropping too deep in search of possession.

Liverpool's Attacking Prowess

Mohamed Salah once again proved to be United's tormentor-in-chief, delivering a masterclass in clinical finishing and intelligent movement. The Egyptian forward was ably supported by his attacking colleagues, who constantly rotated positions and created overloads that United simply couldn't handle.

Liverpool's performance demonstrated the level United must aspire to reach, with their front line combining precision, power and relentless work ethic throughout the ninety minutes.

Ten Hag's Tactical Troubles

The Dutch manager faces increasing scrutiny after this capitulation, with questions mounting about his tactical setup and ability to motivate his players for these crucial fixtures. United looked unprepared for Liverpool's approach, with no clear plan to nullify their opponents' strengths.

Substitutions failed to change the game's momentum, leaving many wondering whether Ten Hag has the solutions to United's ongoing problems. The performance raised serious concerns about the team's direction under his leadership.

Individual Player Assessments

The Standout Disappointments:

  • Defensive units receiving the lowest ratings after multiple errors
  • Midfielders criticised for lack of control and composure
  • Attackers isolated and ineffective for large periods
  • Substitutes failing to make meaningful impact

This defeat leaves Manchester United with mounting problems to solve before their next fixture, while Liverpool continue their pursuit of Premier League glory with this statement victory.