Michael Carrick's position as Manchester United manager is under serious threat after a catastrophic week that included a 4-1 defeat to Como and a 3-0 home loss to Bournemouth. The 45-year-old signed a two-year deal just months ago, but club officials arrived at Carrington on Monday with Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox set to hold crisis talks over his future.
The decision was mulled over after United's tepid 3-0 defeat to the Cherries on Sunday, with the full-time reaction suggesting the outcome for Carrick was inevitable. Despite a defiant front on Friday when previewing Bournemouth's visit, their failings continued, leaving the former midfielder in a perilous position while potential successors line up.
Crisis talks at Carrington
United have a decision to make with a trip to Stamford Bridge to face Chelsea this weekend. Manchester Evening News writers have had their say on who should replace Carrick, with several candidates emerging as favourites.
Kieran Horn argued that regardless of who comes in, United are miles away from where they want to be. He suggested the club should go all out for Unai Emery, who has earned the right to have another crack at a big club following a number of brilliant years at Aston Villa. Horn stressed that Emery must be given time to turn things around, understanding that this is a project requiring several transfer windows.
Pochettino and Howe in the frame
Stephen Killen believes Mauricio Pochettino is the only option to take United forward, noting that the club opted against appointing Eddie Howe following Dan Ashworth's recommendation. Killen pointed to Pochettino's near misses with Tottenham Hotspur in the Premier League and Champions League, and argued that United need his front-footed approach.
Joe Doyle suggested Antonio Conte as the best bet, describing him as a divisive choice but someone who can be flexible with tactics. Doyle argued that United need a manager who commands the players' respect, noting they have consistently downed tools over the last three years. He proposed bringing in Conte on a deal until the end of next season.
Emery and Fabregas among alternatives
Matty Hewitt backed Unai Emery, citing his consistent European football at Aston Villa and Europa League success. He expressed doubts about Eddie Howe after his time at Newcastle United, saying the former Magpies boss looked exhausted and was overly loyal to players past their peak.
Bruna Reis argued that United's problems cannot be solved simply by changing the manager, pointing to issues behind the scenes that have been allowed to continue for years. She questioned whether the manager is really the issue or whether those making decisions above them are responsible, adding that if she had to choose, she would be interested to see Eddie Howe given an opportunity.
Matt Abbott suggested Cesc Fabregas as a left-field option, noting that Como's head coach has effectively killed off Carrick. Fabregas, who is also a minority shareholder at Como, refused to be drawn on the United job before their meeting out of respect for Carrick, but that could change if there is a vacancy.
