Former AFL Star Sues League Over Career-Ending Concussion and Brain Damage
A former premiership-winning Australian Rules footballer has initiated a landmark lawsuit against the Australian Football League, following a devastating on-field head collision that he claims has resulted in permanent brain damage, significant hearing loss, and severe suicidal ideation. Trent Melville, a dual-premiership forward who played for the Nightcliff Tigers in the Northern Territory AFL competition, is taking legal action against the AFL, AFL Northern Territory, and his former club after a traumatic incident during a match in 2022.
Catastrophic Injuries Alleged in Court Documents
Documents filed in the Northern Territory Supreme Court assert that the head clash led to what are described as catastrophic injuries, which have profoundly impacted Melville's health and abruptly terminated his professional football career. The now 33-year-old athlete alleges that he suffered a direct head clash with another player while contesting for the ball during a match on October 15, 2022, leaving him with a serious concussion.
Reflecting on the incident, Melville stated, 'I went to pick up a loose footy and as I stood up I got cleaned up by someone, we smashed heads and I sort of blacked out for a second.' He further explained, 'About a week after my headaches were getting worse, and I drove to work and when I arrived I couldn't remember driving which is when I thought something's not right here.'
Life-Altering Symptoms and Ongoing Struggles
According to the detailed statement of claim, the injury triggered a cascade of debilitating symptoms, including:
- Post-concussion syndrome
- Chronic headaches and migraines
- Significant hearing loss
- Severe insomnia and fatigue
- Persistent memory loss and dizziness
- Suicidal thoughts and ideation
Melville described his ongoing condition, saying, 'At the beginning it was pretty much like chronic migraines, they were unbearable, fatigue, couldn't get out of bed, lots of memory loss and dizziness.' He added, 'I was really struggling and I had to take time off work which settled things a bit; from there it's kind of been a rollercoaster, some days I feel okay and the next I'm feeling terrible.'
Alleged Failure in Duty of Care and Management
The legal claim alleges that the AFL, AFLNT, and the Nightcliff Football Club failed to properly manage Melville's concussion history and permitted him to continue playing despite exhibiting ongoing symptoms. The documents state that he suffered up to seven concussions and numerous sub-concussive blows to the head throughout his career, with memory problems dating back to at least 2017.
Melville argues that he was particularly vulnerable to serious injury from additional head impacts and should have been explicitly warned about the associated risks. He contends that if officials had adequately informed him of the dangers and prevented him from playing while experiencing memory loss, he would not have sustained these catastrophic injuries.
Financial and Personal Impact
The former footballer has detailed the profound personal and financial consequences of his injuries. 'It's impacted my whole life, for pretty much the past year I've struggled to work, had to go part time and that's had a pretty big impact on me financially, I've probably lost half my yearly wages,' Melville revealed.
He further explained, 'I've had to go to a lot of appointments which is stressful, had to change my diet, I can't socialise, I can't do much at all, I pretty much work half a day and then go home. I can't go out and have dinner or a drink, and I can't go to the footy at the moment because the lights are too bright and I can't handle it.'
Mounting Legal Pressure on the AFL
This lawsuit adds to increasing legal scrutiny facing the AFL regarding head injuries and concussion management. Separate legal actions have been brought by other former stars, including Gary Ablett Sr and Liam Picken, alongside a major class action involving dozens of ex-players. Melville is seeking substantial damages, interest, and legal costs through his claim.
None of the defendants have yet filed formal defences to the allegations. The case is scheduled to return to court for a directions hearing in Darwin on March 18, marking a critical next step in this high-profile legal battle.
Support Services: If you or anyone you know needs support, you can contact Lifeline on 131 114, or Beyond Blue on 1300 224 636.
