Former SNP leadership contender Ash Regan has stirred controversy by suggesting that Edinburgh's longstanding Christian holiday should be abolished in favour of a more inclusive 'winter festival'. The proposal, which has drawn mixed reactions, aims to reflect the city's diverse cultural landscape.
Regan, who represents Edinburgh Eastern, argued that the current holiday—rooted in Christian tradition—no longer resonates with many residents. "We must acknowledge that Scotland is becoming increasingly secular," she stated. "A winter festival would better represent our multicultural society."
Mixed Reactions from Politicians and Public
The idea has divided opinion. While some applaud the move towards inclusivity, others accuse Regan of eroding Scotland's cultural heritage. Scottish Conservative MSP Murdo Fraser dismissed the proposal as "another attempt to diminish Christian traditions". Meanwhile, interfaith groups have cautiously welcomed the discussion, urging sensitivity in any changes.
What Would Replace the Holiday?
Regan's vision includes:
- A non-religious winter celebration
- Events showcasing diverse cultural traditions
- Community-focused activities
The MSP emphasised that any changes would require extensive public consultation. "This isn't about removing traditions," she clarified, "but about creating new ones that unite rather than divide."
Political Implications
The timing is notable, coming just months after Regan's leadership bid against Humza Yousaf. Political analysts suggest this move positions her as a progressive voice within the SNP, potentially setting the stage for future policy debates.
As Edinburgh grapples with this proposal, the conversation reflects broader questions about tradition versus modernity in Scotland's evolving identity.
