In a blistering critique that has sent shockwaves through Scottish political circles, SNP MP Joanna Cherry has launched an extraordinary attack on her former boss Nicola Sturgeon, accusing her of employing 'Stalinist' leadership tactics during her time at the helm of the Scottish National Party.
The outspoken Edinburgh South West MP didn't mince words as she reflected on Sturgeon's tenure, suggesting the former First Minister created a culture of fear within the party that stifled open debate. Cherry's comments come as the SNP continues to grapple with internal divisions following Sturgeon's sudden resignation earlier this year.
A Damning Assessment
Cherry, known for her independent streak within the SNP, painted a picture of a party leadership that brooked no dissent under Sturgeon's rule. 'There was a very Stalinesque approach to leadership,' she declared, drawing parallels with the authoritarian Soviet dictator's notorious suppression of opposition.
The MP, who has frequently found herself at odds with the party leadership on issues including gender recognition reforms and the strategy for Scottish independence, suggested the SNP had lost its way under Sturgeon's command.
Party Democracy Under Fire
Central to Cherry's critique was the claim that internal party democracy suffered during Sturgeon's nine years as leader. 'Healthy debate was discouraged,' she asserted, 'and those who dared to voice alternative opinions often found themselves marginalised or excluded.'
This explosive intervention comes at a sensitive time for the SNP, which has seen its poll ratings slip since Humza Yousaf took over as leader and First Minister. Political analysts suggest Cherry's comments may embolden other critics within the party to speak out.
Sturgeon's Legacy Questioned
While acknowledging Sturgeon's electoral successes and popularity with the Scottish public, Cherry questioned whether these achievements came at too high a cost to the SNP's internal culture. 'Winning elections is important,' she conceded, 'but not if it means sacrificing the principles of open discussion and collective decision-making that our party was founded upon.'
The remarks have sparked fierce debate within Scottish political circles, with some SNP figures rushing to defend Sturgeon's record while others privately express sympathy with Cherry's assessment.
What This Means for the SNP
Political observers suggest this public airing of grievances reflects deeper tensions within the SNP as it adjusts to life after Sturgeon. The party faces significant challenges on multiple fronts, including:
- Rebuilding unity after a divisive leadership contest
- Regaining momentum in the independence campaign
- Addressing policy disagreements that were suppressed under Sturgeon's leadership
As the SNP prepares for crucial elections in the coming years, Cherry's intervention raises questions about whether the party can heal its internal divisions while maintaining its dominant position in Scottish politics.
