The Carmel City Council has voted to advance a permanent ordinance that would extend a temporary ban on pickleball at Forest Hill Park, following complaints from nearby residents about noise. The park, located just five blocks from Ocean Avenue, is home to the only public pickleball courts within city limits.
The temporary ban was initially imposed in October to test sound-mitigation strategies such as quiet paddles and soft balls. However, residents argued that these compromises were unenforceable without formal supervision, as the park lacks a dedicated parks department or consistent staff.
Resident Kimberly Edwards, who supports the ban, told the council that the city had no way to enforce quieter play. 'These aren’t supervised courts,' she said. 'Who’s going to enforce this? ... Am I going to have to hear a noise and then call the police?'
Competitive pickleball player Barbara Lang urged the council not to ban the sport, arguing that even a quiet version would be better than eliminating play entirely. 'If you want to try it with the quiet ball, I think it’s only fair to the players to give that a chance,' she said.
The council voted unanimously to maintain the temporary ban and directed the city attorney to draft a permanent ban, which opponents can appeal in two future hearings. Mayor Dale Byrne supported the move, saying it would spare residents from further disputes and noting that enforcement would be difficult.
Police Chief Todd Trayer said enforcement would only occur if someone reports an issue, but no reports have been received. He added that the pickleball community has other local options not far away.