Robert Sugden is one of Emmerdale's most iconic characters, but many fans may not recall the original actor who first brought him to life. While Ryan Hawley has played the role since 2014, the character was originally portrayed by Karl Davis from 2001 to 2005, with a brief return in 2009.
Karl Davis was the third actor to play Robert, following Richard Smith, who appeared as a baby in 1986. During his tenure, Davis was involved in major storylines, including a feud with brother Andy and an affair with Andy's wife Katie. The controversial plots sometimes sparked real-life reactions; Davis once told the Daily Record that he was hit by a handbag and often scolded by fans for Robert's cheating.
After leaving Emmerdale in 2009, Davis pursued other acting opportunities. He turned down a return in 2014, leading to Ryan Hawley's casting. Producer Kate Oates confirmed they had approached Davis first but understood his decision. Davis later said he hadn't watched the show since leaving, but wished the new Robert well.
Since his departure, Davis has built a successful career with roles in Game of Thrones, Call the Midwife, Happy Valley, and The Bay. In September 2023, he was cast in Waterloo Road as Tony Walters, alongside Kym Marsh, for an intense storyline.
