The annual tradition of a new Agatha Christie adaptation continues, but this year's offering on Netflix, 'The Seven Dials Mystery', has sparked debate about the direction of these classic whodunits. Moving away from the darker, postwar-inflected versions recently seen on the BBC, this three-part series returns to a world of clipped vowels and country house intrigue, with mixed results.
A Puzzling Start in Ronda and a Grand House Party
The story opens dramatically in 1920s Ronda, with a gruesome death involving a bull and a cryptic note featuring a clock. The action then shifts to a lavish party at a grand English estate, rented by the newly wealthy, class-conscious Coote family from the cash-poor but aristocratic Lady Caterham, played by Helena Bonham Carter.
At the party, Lady Eileen 'Bundle' Brent, portrayed by Mia McKenna-Bruce, is courted by her late brother's friend, Gerry Wade. The potential romance is cut short when Wade is found dead the next morning from an apparent sleeping draught overdose—a puzzling end for a man known as a famously sound sleeper. The discovery of seven alarm clocks arranged on his mantelpiece, when eight were originally hidden as a prank, sets the central mystery in motion.
An Investigation Plagued by Clichés
Frustrated by the bumbling local police, Bundle takes the investigation into her own hands. The narrative unfolds through a series of classic Christie tropes: tell-tale stains, anonymous notes, and trips to London. However, the script, penned by Chris Chibnall, is frequently criticised for leaning into period drama clichés and social caricatures, with dialogue that often feels more functional than natural.
The review suggests the adaptation has a tone reminiscent of Enid Blyton, crafted for an international audience with a particular, perhaps romanticised, view of British aristocracy. It is described as 'retro without flair', more concerned with moving plot pieces than building genuine suspense or character depth.
Martin Freeman Brings Gravitas as Superintendent Battle
The series finds its footing with the belated arrival of Martin Freeman as Superintendent Battle. The actor brings a much-needed weight and credibility to the proceedings, his understated and authoritative performance cutting through the otherwise pedestrian pace. Freeman's instinctive grasp of the material is highlighted as a key strength, providing a focal point that the earlier episodes lack.
His character's entry brings order to the chaotic investigation, mirroring how Freeman's presence elevates the televisual experience. Yet, the question remains whether his performance is enough to sustain viewers through all three hour-long episodes of what is meant to be an espionage thriller.
Final Verdict on a Pedestrian Adaptation
Ultimately, 'Agatha Christie's Seven Dials' is seen as a missed opportunity. While it delivers the requisite puzzle-box plot, it lacks the atmospheric tension and adult sophistication of recent adaptations. The blend of period setting with oddly modern sensibilities about emotional wellbeing is noted as a jarring mix that fails to convince.
For die-hard Christie fans, the mystery may hold some appeal, and Martin Freeman's performance is a standout. However, for those seeking the rich, dark complexity the author's work can offer, this Netflix venture may feel like a step back into a more simplistic, and less inspired, era of adaptation.
Agatha Christie's Seven Dials is available to stream on Netflix now.
