The BBC’s new crime drama Lynley, based on Elizabeth George’s novels, has received a mixed response from viewers. The series, which updates the classic detective duo for a contemporary audience, stars Leo Suter as the aristocratic DI Tommy Lynley and Sofia Barclay as his working-class partner DS Barbara Havers. Critics have noted the show’s reliance on familiar tropes, with one review describing it as “the ultimate undemanding telly”.
The plot follows Lynley and Havers investigating the murder of a wealthy island owner, Guy Brouard, who is found bludgeoned to death. The case involves a range of suspects, including Brouard’s wife, son, housekeeper, and a female student, with subplots involving sex tapes and pottery shards. The show has been praised for its steady pacing and tight plotting, but some viewers have criticised its lack of originality and depth.
Viewers have taken to social media to express their disappointment, with many comparing the reboot unfavourably to the original series starring Nathaniel Parker and Sharon Small, which aired from 2001 to 2008. One viewer wrote: “This new Lynley feels like a pale imitation of the original. The chemistry just isn’t there.” Others have questioned the need for a reboot, given the enduring popularity of the earlier adaptation.
Despite the criticism, the show has its defenders, who appreciate its undemanding nature and the performances of the leads. Leo Suter’s portrayal of Lynley has been described as “unusually buff for a posho”, while Sofia Barclay brings a feisty energy to Havers. The series also features a supporting cast including Daniel Mays as Lynley’s antagonistic boss and Niamh Walsh as his love interest.
As the first episode sets up various mysteries and character arcs, it remains to be seen whether Lynley will win over audiences or fade into obscurity. For now, it offers a comfortable, if unremarkable, addition to the BBC’s crime drama lineup.
