ITV's highly anticipated new drama, Coldwater, has been plunged into an ice bath of scathing criticism following its premiere, with lead star Andrew Lincoln failing to warm up reviewers.
The Independent's television critic, Nick Hilton, delivered a particularly frosty verdict, branding the series a "profoundly dull affair" that is "entirely unconvincing" from its opening moments. The show, which marks Lincoln's major return to British television since The Walking Dead, appears to have missed the mark entirely.
A Chilly Reception for a Big-Budget Return
Hilton's review pulls no punches, stating the drama's supposedly shocking central twist is "immediately obvious" to the viewer, creating a frustrating disconnect as the characters remain oblivious. This failure to build suspense or intrigue seems to be the series' core weakness.
The critic went further, questioning the very decision to schedule the show in the coveted Sunday night slot, traditionally reserved for ITV's biggest and most reliable hits. The implication is clear: Coldwater lacks the quality and broad appeal expected of such a prime-time offering.
Lincoln's Charisma Not Enough to Thaw the Plot
While Andrew Lincoln is acknowledged as a "perfectly good actor," the review suggests his efforts are in service of a lacklustre script and a poorly conceived character. His portrayal of disgraced police officer John Peterson was criticised for failing to evoke the necessary intrigue or sympathy, leaving the audience cold.
The surrounding cast and the show's visual language also came under fire for failing to elevate the material or create a compelling atmosphere, resulting in a flat and unengaging viewing experience.
For fans eagerly awaiting Lincoln's British TV comeback, Coldwater seems to be, by this critic's account, a disappointing and forgettable misstep that fails to capitalise on its star's pedigree or its prime scheduling.
