John Early, best known for playing toxic millennials in shows like Search Party, has grown tired of being typecast as a lunatic. The 37-year-old actor says he noticed people were scared of him in real life, convinced he would judge or mock them. 'Like what am I putting out into the world?' he recalls thinking.
Early specialised in playing gay millennial narcissists, from the ruthless Elliott in Search Party to a man spiralling over a plantation wedding in a Netflix sketch. He says his progressive Presbyterian upbringing in Nashville made playing psychos more appealing than nice guys. 'There was electricity to playing a psycho,' he explains.
Now Early is promoting Eternity, an A24 romcom starring Miles Teller and Elizabeth Olsen. He plays a soul-ferrier alongside Da'Vine Joy Randolph, and the pair were originally meant to kiss. 'We were supposed to kiss, but on our last day of shooting, we were like… we're not doing that, right?' Early says. 'There's something funnier about our characters just stating out of nowhere that they're in love.'
Early bonded with Randolph over being 'consummate, flexible supporting actors', a role he embraces. He reflects on the shift in his career, moving away from the millennial monsters that made his name. 'I felt this thing happen over and over again where I was like… oh! People are scared of me,' he says, adding that it made him reconsider the work he was making.