A landmark court decision has confirmed the legality of isolation booths in English schools, reigniting the debate over student welfare and disciplinary practices.
What the Ruling Means
The High Court dismissed a legal challenge against the use of isolation booths, stating they do not inherently violate children's rights when used appropriately. This judgment supports schools in maintaining discipline while allowing for individual cases to be reviewed.
Key Arguments in the Case
- For: Schools argue isolation is necessary to maintain order and protect other students' learning.
- Against: Campaigners claim prolonged isolation can harm mental health and educational progress.
Current Guidelines
Department for Education guidance permits isolation as a disciplinary measure but requires:
- Reasonable duration
- Access to toilet facilities
- Provision of work
- Regular welfare checks
What Happens Next?
While the ruling provides clarity, education unions warn of potential overuse. The government maintains that headteachers should retain discretion over disciplinary methods.
The decision comes amid growing scrutiny of school behaviour policies, with calls for more transparent monitoring of isolation practices.
