A Democratic candidate positioned to become San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie's key ally is facing significant opposition from police unions after advocating for officers to patrol without firearms in the crime-affected city.
Police Union Backlash Against Progressive Candidate
Natalie Gee has emerged as a leading contender for the Sunset District supervisor position at City Hall, despite vigorous opposition from the local police union. The union president, Louis Wong, has publicly condemned Gee's law enforcement views, describing them as deeply concerning.
In a strongly worded letter to Mayor Lurie obtained by The San Francisco Chronicle, Wong accused Gee of having "the desire to silence the collective voice of the rank-and-file officers who keep this city safe." The police union has mobilised against her potential appointment, creating a significant political challenge for the mayor.
Gee's Controversial Police Reform Proposals
Gee's progressive policing stance became public through her responses to a 2024 candidate questionnaire. She expressed support for dissolving the police union and fundamentally changing how officers approach public safety.
Her most controversial proposal involves replacing firearms with "tasers and non-lethal weapons" for routine police work. Additionally, Gee advocates for eliminating qualified immunity, the legal protection that shields officers and public officials from certain lawsuits.
On her campaign website, Gee elaborates on her vision for community policing, stating she wants to get officers "out of their cars and back onto neighborhood beats, where they can prevent crime through visibility and connection."
San Francisco's Complex Crime Landscape
The debate over policing reforms occurs against a backdrop of mixed crime statistics in San Francisco. While citywide crime has decreased by 25 percent compared to last year, specific areas continue to struggle with significant public safety challenges.
Union Square has become particularly problematic, with residents avoiding the zone due to rampant fentanyl use, frequent thefts, and violence. The Tenderloin district has been plagued by uncontrolled homeless encampments and persistent crime, forcing major retail brands to close their flagship stores.
Mayor Lurie has identified public safety as his primary priority, focusing on cleaning up downtown areas and cracking down on drug-related crimes. During a recent visit to the Sunset District, he emphasised that safety represents a huge priority for the community.
Gee's potential district, Sunset, is considered one of San Francisco's safer neighbourhoods, positioned across the city from the troubled Tenderloin area.
Broader Political Implications and Response
Wong's opposition extends beyond Gee's policing views. The union president highlighted to Mayor Lurie that Gee has donated to anti-police causes, supports dissolving ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement), and advocates for reparations among other progressive policies.
In response to the criticism, Gee has expressed willingness to collaborate, telling The Chronicle she would "welcome the opportunity to meet with" Wong to "work toward a real solution." She emphasised her commitment to unity and collaboration in a public statement.
Gee currently serves as an aide to Supervisor Shamann Walton and faces competition from three other candidates for the Sunset District role. If selected by Mayor Lurie, she would initially hold the position on an interim basis but has stated her intention to run for the seat permanently this summer.
The vacancy emerged when former supervisor Beya Alcaraz resigned just one week into her tenure following allegations about questionable business practices related to a pet store she previously operated.
