A judge overseeing the high-profile Sheku Bayoh inquiry has defiantly refused to step down, despite mounting pressure from police lawyers who allege potential bias in the proceedings.
The controversial case, which examines the circumstances surrounding Bayoh's death in police custody in 2015, has taken a dramatic turn as legal representatives for the officers involved have threatened judicial review proceedings unless the judge withdraws.
Legal Standoff Emerges
Courtroom tensions reached new heights this week as police counsel argued the judge's previous comments about the case created an appearance of prejudice. However, in a strongly worded rebuttal, the judge maintained his position was impartial and that the inquiry would proceed as scheduled.
Background of the Case
Sheku Bayoh, a 31-year-old father of two, died after being restrained by multiple officers in Kirkcaldy, Scotland. His family has campaigned tirelessly for answers about the circumstances of his death, which occurred within hours of being taken into custody.
The current inquiry represents the latest chapter in this nearly decade-long legal battle, examining whether institutional racism played any role in the incident and subsequent investigation.
What Happens Next?
Legal experts suggest the police legal team now faces a critical decision:
- Proceed with their threatened judicial review application
- Continue participating in the inquiry under the current judge
- Seek alternative legal avenues to address their concerns
The inquiry's next hearing date remains set, though observers note the proceedings risk being overshadowed by this unprecedented challenge to judicial authority.
