In the battle of the supermarket coconut yoghurts, we put Aldi's and Sainsbury's offerings to the ultimate test – and the winner wasn't what we expected.
The Great Coconut Yoghurt Showdown
With dairy-free alternatives booming in popularity, we conducted a blind taste test comparing two of Britain's favourite supermarket coconut yoghurts. On one side, Aldi's budget-friendly option; on the other, Sainsbury's premium alternative.
The Contenders
- Aldi's The Coconut Collaborative Natural Yogurt Alternative (£1.69 for 400g)
- Sainsbury's Coconut Collaborative Natural Yogurt Alternative (£2.20 for 400g)
Texture Test
The first noticeable difference was in texture. Aldi's version had a remarkably creamy consistency that closely resembled traditional dairy yoghurt. Sainsbury's offering, while smooth, was slightly thinner and more liquid.
Flavour Face-Off
When it came to taste, both yoghurts delivered that distinctive coconut flavour, but with surprising differences:
- Aldi's yoghurt had a balanced sweetness with subtle tanginess
- Sainsbury's version was noticeably sweeter but lacked depth of flavour
- The natural coconut taste came through more clearly in the Aldi product
The Verdict
In a shock result, our taste test panel overwhelmingly preferred Aldi's coconut yoghurt, praising its superior texture and more authentic flavour profile. The fact that it's significantly cheaper (£0.51 less per pot) makes this victory even sweeter for budget-conscious shoppers.
"For nearly a third less money, you're actually getting a better product," remarked one tester. "Aldi has managed to create a coconut yoghurt that's creamier, more flavoursome, and better value – it's a rare supermarket hat-trick."
Why This Matters
With vegan and dairy-free diets becoming increasingly mainstream, the quality of supermarket alternatives has never been more important. This test proves that premium pricing doesn't always guarantee superior quality, and that savvy shoppers can enjoy great-tasting plant-based products without breaking the bank.
