The owner of a controversial home on Awkward Hill in Bibury, often called England's prettiest street, is facing renewed anger over plans for a large outdoor fireplace and an underground car park. Metin Dener, who owns Rosemary Cottage, has submitted new applications despite fierce opposition from neighbours and the parish council.
The parish council has objected to the outdoor fireplace, calling it "huge" and "not in keeping with its surroundings," particularly given the cottage's Grade II listed status. It said the chimney can be seen from various angles, altering the historic view, and accused the owner of a "flagrant disregard for the history and beauty of the area."
Local residents have expressed outrage, with one describing the transformation of the "tiny Cotswolds cottage" into a "monstrosity" after nearly three years of building work. They have complained about constant noise, disruption, and trucks churning up verges and blocking gates.
In response, the applicant's representatives argued that the works have only increased the property's footprint by 1.2 square metres and replaced an above-ground garage with an underground one. They blamed slow progress on the narrow access road and high tourist numbers, and said contractors had tried to inform residents of deliveries.
The latest applications include a part-retrospective plan for the fireplace and landscaping, as well as details for underground car park materials. Previous proposals for a conservatory and summerhouse were withdrawn in January, while other works have involved roof repairs and insulation.
