Bargain £25 Perfume Beats Designer £95 Scent in Which? Blind Test
Bargain £25 Perfume Beats Designer £95 Scent in Which? Blind Test

A blind test by consumer group Which? has found that a budget perfume costing £24.99 outperformed a designer fragrance priced at £95. The trial involved more than 40 volunteers who sniffed decanted scents without knowing their brands.

The Essence Vault 82, priced at £24.99 for 100ml, was preferred over Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium, which costs £95 for 50ml. Testers described the dupe as warm, sweet and lightly spicy with musky and woody notes, despite an initial chemical hit.

In other comparisons, Jo Malone's Peony & Blush Cologne (£122 for 100ml) narrowly beat Aldi's Hotel Collection Peony Blush (£6.49). Miss Dior (£107 for 100ml) also edged out Perfume Parlour's Realistic for Women (£32 for 100ml), though testers noted the dupe was a solid alternative.

Rabanne 1 Million (£66 for 50ml) outperformed its dupe Noted Aromas Las Vegas (£29.99 for 100ml), with the cheaper version fading faster and having a stronger ethanol smell. Overall, designer scents lasted around three hours, while many dupes weakened after an hour.

Which? concluded that budget perfumes can hold their own against luxury brands, making them a smart choice for cost-conscious shoppers this Christmas.