Sir Keir Starmer is facing mounting criticism within his own party after appointing former Labour MP John Mann as the government's independent adviser on anti-semitism, a move that has sparked controversy and accusations of cronyism.
Peerage Appointment Sparks Internal Conflict
The Labour leader's decision to elevate Mann to the House of Lords has created significant unrest among party members and MPs. The former Bassetlaw MP, who served for 18 years before stepping down in 2019, will now take on the crucial role of combating anti-semitism within political circles.
Mann's appointment comes with a life peerage, granting him a permanent seat in the upper chamber. This move has raised eyebrows among critics who question the timing and motivation behind the selection.
Mixed Reactions from Political Allies and Foes
While some colleagues have welcomed Mann's extensive experience in tackling anti-semitism, others have expressed deep concerns about the appointment process. The controversy centres around whether the peerage represents a genuine commitment to addressing anti-semitism or merely rewards political loyalty.
One senior Labour source revealed: "There are genuine questions being asked about whether this is the right appointment and whether due process was followed. Many are uncomfortable with how this has been handled."
Background of Political Service
John Mann built his reputation as a backbench MP known for speaking his mind, often criticising his own party's leadership when he disagreed with their direction. His departure from Parliament in 2019 marked the end of an era for the constituency he had represented since 2001.
During his tenure, Mann developed expertise in combating anti-semitism, serving on various committees and leading initiatives to address religious discrimination in politics and wider society.
Ongoing Challenges for Labour Leadership
This appointment comes at a sensitive time for Starmer, who has been working to rebuild trust within the party and address long-standing issues around discrimination. The Labour leader has made tackling anti-semitism a key priority since taking over the leadership.
However, critics argue that the manner of Mann's appointment undermines the party's commitment to transparency and could potentially damage public confidence in the anti-semitism advisory role.
The Department of Health and Social Care, which will oversee Mann's work, has yet to comment on the specific nature of his responsibilities or the terms of his appointment.
