Craig Guildford, the chief constable of West Midlands Police, has retired with immediate effect following a damning inquiry into the force's decision to ban fans of Israeli football club Maccabi Tel Aviv from a match. The inquiry found that 'greatly exaggerated' intelligence was used to justify the ban, leading to a loss of confidence from Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood and Prime Minister Keir Starmer.
Guildford, 52, had initially resisted calls to resign, believing he could hold on until Police and Crime Commissioner Simon Foster decided his fate. However, mounting criticism from cabinet ministers and fellow police chiefs, who warned his continued tenure risked damaging the police's reputation nationally, forced his hand. He will retire on a full pension after 32 years of service.
The controversy stems from advice given by West Midlands Police to Birmingham's safety advisory group in October, which claimed that Maccabi Tel Aviv fans were too dangerous to attend a Europa League match against Aston Villa on 6 November. The force cited intelligence from Dutch police, but this was later disputed by the Dutch authorities, and the intelligence case gradually unravelled.
An official report by Chief Inspector of Constabulary Andy Cooke attacked the force's credibility, and Mahmood said the findings were 'damning' and had 'harmed trust' in the force. She welcomed Guildford's retirement as a 'crucial first step to rebuilding trust and confidence'. Guildford stated that the 'political and media frenzy' had become detrimental to the force's work, and that retirement was in the best interests of the organisation and his family.
Simon Foster, the police and crime commissioner, said Guildford had 'acted with honour' and that his retirement prevented a potentially costly legal battle. Deputy Chief Constable Scott Green will take over temporarily while Foster seeks a permanent replacement. The home secretary is expected to use a forthcoming police reform white paper to gain the power to sack failing chiefs directly.