Kingston Council has lost its appeal against a High Court ruling that it overcharged tenants for water, potentially leaving it liable for millions of pounds in refunds. The Court of Appeal upheld a previous judgment that the council acted as a water reseller rather than an agent, meaning it unlawfully failed to pass on discounts to tenants.
The ruling applies to overcharges dating back to April 1, 2002. Law firm Deighton Pierce Glynn, which represented the tenant in the case, said the decision appears to be final on councils' attempts to portray their arrangements with Thames Water as agency deals. The court unanimously found that the council's sale of water to tenants constituted a resale, requiring it to pass on negotiated discounts under the Water Resale Orders 2001 and 2006.
Deighton Pierce Glynn began representing tenants after noticing large numbers facing eviction for non-payment of water rates, which would not have been possible if Thames Water had supplied them directly. The firm said the judgment confirms that Kingston is liable to refund the difference to its 4,600 tenants.
Inside Housing reported that the south-west London authority could now be liable for millions in compensation. The Court of Appeal found “no real doubt” that Thames Water supplied water to the council, not directly to tenants, and confirmed the reasoning from the landmark 2016 case Jones v Southwark London Borough Council, which established that hundreds of thousands of tenants had been overcharged for decades.
A Kingston Council spokesperson said: “We are aware of the judgement and this has brought clarity to the situation. We are now considering the response to the ruling and the actions we need to put in place. We will provide further information soon.”