South Ayrshire green waste facility plan ruled unviable
South Ayrshire green waste facility plan ruled unviable

Plans for a council-operated garden waste treatment facility in South Ayrshire appear unlikely to proceed in their current form after an officer confirmed the business case was no longer viable.

The development was intended to provide a dedicated site for processing green and garden waste collected by South Ayrshire Council. However, members of the Service and Partnerships Performance Panel heard on Tuesday, November 17, that significant difficulties identifying and purchasing suitable land had prevented the project from progressing.

Project Missed Multiple Milestones

The council’s latest performance report had already identified the scheme as off track, with the project assessed as 65 per cent complete. Original targets included securing a site by October 2024 and having the facility operational by July 2025. However, the most recent milestone of July 2026 was also missed.

During Tuesday’s meeting, Councillor George Weir raised the issue of the project, saying: “I’m just wondering if this is effectively abandoned.”

Officer Confirms Business Case Not Viable

Fiona Ross, Service Lead for Neighbourhood Services, replied: “I wouldn’t disagree with your comment councillor. We have had significant issues in trying to identify and purchase land and we now feel that the business case is no longer viable in its current format.”

She confirmed that South Ayrshire Council would continue its existing green waste recycling arrangements, including work with its golf services to recycle waste from council-operated courses. Ms Ross then referred to recent discussions around a new structure for local government, which has returned to the possibility of a single Ayrshire council.

Potential Reassessment if Councils Merge

She said: “If the authorities were to merge, then I think that that would be the time to reassess the business case for the processing of all green waste within the authorities.”

The project is one of 22 actions being monitored through the council’s 2023–2028 Council Plan. The latest report identifies 16 actions as on track, two as completed, one as off track and three requiring their deadlines to be reassessed. No new timetable or replacement scheme for the garden waste treatment facility was confirmed during the discussion.