Essar Oil (UK) Limited has been ordered to pay £873,473 at Warrington Magistrates’ Court after pleading guilty to 12 offences brought by the Environment Agency. The company breached environmental permit limits at least 489 times between 2018 and 2020 at its Stanlow Manufacturing Complex in Ellesmere Port, with pollutants including oil, suspended solids and chemicals such as cyanide discharged into local waterways.
Fines and penalties
The company was fined £80,000 for each of 10 offences, alongside £73,473 in costs. No additional penalty was imposed for two further charges relating to separate incidents in 2019. The 10 main offences involved the refinery exceeding permitted limits for trade effluent, which was subsequently discharged into Thornton Brook, the River Gowy and the Manchester Ship Canal.
Separate incidents in 2019
Two further incidents highlighted separate failures at the site. In February 2019, between 15 and 20 tonnes of a chemical used to remove hydrogen gas leaked into the drainage system and entered the Manchester Ship Canal. An investigation found that a vent had been left open and a written procedure had not been followed. The company described the incident as a "conscious deviation from operating procedures".
The following month, a contractor's vehicle reversed into an effluent pipe, causing a rupture. During repairs, which were not fully completed until April, around 15 tonnes of partially treated sewage was discharged into Thornton Brook, which flows towards the Mersey Estuary.
Environmental impact
The Mersey Estuary is protected under several conservation designations, including as a Site of Special Scientific Interest and a wetland of international importance. The estuary provides important habitats for birds and supports fish migration routes. The person responsible for the vehicle incident was banned from the site, while investigators found that the risks associated with vehicle movements had not been properly assessed.
Environment Agency officers visited the refinery on several occasions and reported seeing a silver sheen of oil on Thornton Brook, the River Gowy and the Manchester Ship Canal. In January 2020, vegetation downstream of the refinery's discharge point was also found to be black with oil.
Nigel Glasgow, area environment manager at the Environment Agency, said: "Oil refineries are some of the largest industrial facilities we regulate, and they operate under environmental permits designed to protect our rivers, seas and wildlife. This case demonstrates a repeated failure to comply with those permit conditions, with at least 489 exceedances over a three-year period. Operators have a fundamental responsibility to properly manage their sites, and where they fail to do so we will hold them to account. We will continue to regulate the facility rigorously, investigate breaches and take enforcement action where necessary."