Four months after the roof of Capel Seion (Zion Chapel) in Merthyr Tydfil caved in, urgent works to make the Grade II-listed building safe have just been completed. The road outside the chapel on Twynyrodyn Road has been closed for more than 19 weeks following reports of falling debris from residents on July 8.
A dangerous structure notice was issued that day, and within hours the building's roof collapsed. Council officers and accredited conservation engineers inspected the structure and identified the partial or full collapse of the first-floor balconies due to overloading and further deterioration. They also found that the masonry parapets at the front of the building had collapsed and that there was further movement of unstable debris.
Residents Describe the Aftermath
Wendy Owen and Teresa Richards, who live nearby, said they did not hear the collapse happen but saw the aftermath. Teresa commented on the loss, saying: "It is sad to see. It is a lovely building. It has taken such a long time." She added that the condition would have worsened during the winter months.
Wendy noted that lorries usually travel up and down the road, so any noise could be mistaken for a lorry. However, she said the road had become much quieter as traffic has been diverted. "I don't think the people next door heard anything. They were just told they had to move," she said. Teresa added: "I have been here for 38 years and never seen it in use." Wendy recalled concerts at the chapel when her children were in school but said they do not know what the building will be used for next.
Evacuation and Temporary Relocation
Daniel Ben Stephen had to move out for a couple of weeks after the collapse. He and his family initially relocated to the Castle Hotel but could not stay there because they have a very young child, so they stayed elsewhere until they could move back in on July 27. He welcomed plans to renovate the structure, describing it as "not looking great" without a roof. He said: "It will be great when it comes to have a roof," and added: "It will be more amazing. It is a monument."
Urgent Works and Legal Framework
Section 144 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023 allows a local authority to carry out any works it considers urgently necessary for the preservation of a listed building, subject to specified exemptions, and requires at least seven clear days written notice to the owner before works are carried out. The legislation also allows for the recovery of the authority's reasonable costs.
A report stated that the building's condition meant any delay would significantly increase the risk of irreversible loss of historic fabric, structural instability, harm to the heritage significance of the asset, and potential risks to public safety. The report said the decision could not reasonably wait for the council's committee cycle without prejudicing the authority's ability to fulfil its statutory responsibilities as a local planning authority. Although the council's constitution does not currently refer to powers under section 144 of the 2023 act, the report noted that given the urgent circumstances, it was not practicable to wait for a decision through the ordinary committee process. It stated that the power falls within the council's statutory functions relating to the protection of the historic environment.
The council report said it had received four quotes for the works, ranging from £20,631.65 to £45,974.50. The council will seek recovery of all reasonable costs from the owner and is also working with Cadw to secure grant funding that could cover 80% of the costs up to a maximum of £50,000. The report noted there is no guarantee regarding recovery of costs. The report's recommendations were that the chief executive authorises the service of an urgent works notice, authorises officers to carry out or procure works considered urgently necessary for the preservation of the building should the owner fail to do so within the statutory notice period, and authorises the recovery of all reasonable costs incurred by the council.