Environment Minister Steve Luce has officially scrapped proposals to ban the import of second-hand petrol and diesel vehicles from 2030 in Jersey, declaring the plan is "clearly not widely supported" and highlighting critical affordability issues for island residents.
Public Consultation Drives Policy Reversal
In a ministerial statement to the States, Luce revealed that over 200 responses from individuals and businesses were received during the consultation on the vehicle proposals. He noted that while he is still analysing the submissions, there is "overwhelming support to modify the approach envisaged in the Carbon Neutral Roadmap." The original blueprint had outlined beginning the phase-out and halting the importation of petrol and diesel vehicles from 2030 onwards, but Luce maintained the scheme lacked broad backing.
Affordability at the Heart of Decision
Luce emphasised that "affordability" for motorists played a crucial role in the decision. He stated, "Retaining the flow of used petrol and diesel vehicles into the island will help enable a more just transition for islanders, ensuring the burden of change does not unnecessarily impact on those worst off." He added, "We must take steps to ensure affordability both at the point of purchase and for vehicle servicing and repairs. This is critical to preserving customer choice and ensuring that islanders can manage the costs associated with day to day motoring."
Economic Impact and Emissions Considerations
The U-turn was not solely based on public opinion; Luce explained it was also shaped by a preliminary economic impact assessment he had received. He acknowledged that "careful consideration of the impact on emissions" would be required moving forward. Politicians had previously approved phasing out all petrol and diesel vehicles as part of Jersey's Carbon Neutral Roadmap, mirroring the UK's approach, but this revision marks a significant shift.
Uncertainty Over New Vehicle Policy
Luce offered no indication whether a comparable policy affecting new cars would be abandoned. He revealed he is "reserving judgement" on this matter, pending a full review of consultation responses. However, he cautioned, "New cars may be a challenge as well," citing mounting concerns that UK car manufacturers are showing reluctance to export electric vehicles for sale to the Channel Islands.
In conclusion, the minister confirmed, "We will not be looking to universally restrict the importation and registration of used vehicles," effectively overhauling the policy for second-hand petrol and diesel cars while leaving the future for new vehicles under review.
