Close to 200 countries met in Antalya, Turkey, for the annual UN climate summit, Cop31, as the planet faces the devastating impacts of unprecedented human-caused global heating. The talks ended with significant divides unresolved, particularly over fossil fuels and finance.
Fossil Fuels and the Antalya Pact
The talks fell apart over the refusal by some countries to allow mention of fossil fuels in the final "cover decision" text, known as the "Antalya pact," and the refusal of others to agree an outcome without it. For most people watching, it will seem absurd for a climate conference not to address the actual cause of global heating.
The EU, the UK, a handful of other rich nations, and scores of developing countries, including the most vulnerable small islands and least developed countries, joined a loose coalition of about 130 parties on Saturday night to demand recognition of the need to "transition away from fossil fuels" in the final outcome. Their demands failed, but the issue will not go away. All countries agreed to "transition away from fossil fuels" at Cop28 in Dubai in 2023, and that promise still stands, but refusing to talk about fossil fuels seems no longer a tenable position for the only global climate forum.
Finance Takes Center Stage
Although developing nations made up the majority of the 130 countries in the "progressive coalition," many did not object to the "Antalya pact" in the final session, because finance was a more salient issue for them than fossil fuels. An increasing number of poor countries are in a debt crisis driven by the Covid pandemic, inflation, and the failure of rich countries to acknowledge the problem, compounded by the impacts of extreme weather.
Many are spending more on coping with the impacts of global heating on crop yields, infrastructure, and disasters than on core budgets such as health and education. Rich countries have promised money to help them adapt and shift to low-carbon economies. At Cop29 in Baku in 2024, rich countries pledged $300bn a year to the poor world by 2035 from publicly funded sources and to facilitate $1tn in additional funding from private sector sources, but that money has been slow to reach the countries that need it most.
Key demands from poor countries, particularly in Africa, were to make good on the promise of tripling finance for adaptation. They felt unheard and were angry. "We did not come here to beg," African ministers told the Cop. Australia also made a strategic error by failing to engage parties with finance at an early stage, repeatedly saying "this is not a finance Cop," which did not go down well with developing countries.
Overshoot and Presidency Challenges
Global temperatures have risen higher than 1.5C above preindustrial levels, and within a few years this is likely to be judged a permanent state unless strong action is taken. For the first time, this Cop recognised and began to discuss the "overshoot" of the 1.5C target, though there was no agreement on what to do about it.
For the first time, this Cop had two presidencies. Both insisted throughout that the arrangement was working well, with Chris Bowen, the Australian president of negotiations, saying he could not understand how single country presidencies of the past had coped. But when it comes to crunch negotiations with 195 countries, consulting two presidencies takes twice as long. The gaps between the first draft of the cover decision on Monday, the second draft on Thursday, and the third draft in the early hours of Sunday morning, followed by a fourth and final draft on Sunday afternoon, showed how difficult it was for the joint presidencies to coordinate at speed.
Electrification and Unbridgeable Divides
Pushing for renewable energy to replace fossil fuel power generation has been the work of decades, but it is finally an "unstoppable" process, helped by dramatic falls in the price of wind, solar panels, and batteries. Power generation makes up a minority of fossil fuel use; the rest is transport, heating, and industrial uses. Unless these can also be decarbonised, the world will fail to meet its net zero greenhouse gas emissions goal.
Electric vehicles are now nearly as cheap as internal combustion engine cars, heat pumps have been widely adopted in some countries, and electrified industrial processes are now coming on stream. Cop31 failed to agree the goal of deriving 35% of energy from electricity by 2035, but it did succeed in putting electrification firmly on the map.
Cops work by consensus, and some countries have called for reform of the process. Bowen told reporters at the end of Cop31 that "unbridgeable divides" among countries had made agreement impossible. This poses a serious question for Cop32, next year in Ethiopia. If the process is to keep going, these divides must be recognised and countries must work to find common ground, long before the next Cop begins.