Paedophile used neighbour's wi-fi for child abuse images
Paedophile used neighbour's wi-fi for abuse images

A paedophile who claimed he had no internet at home was using a neighbour's wi-fi without the neighbour's knowledge, a court has heard.

Police had swooped on David Smith's property after receiving information from the National Crime Agency (NCA) about his online activities. Swansea Crown Court heard that when police asked 68-year-old Smith where the Motorola phone which the NCA had told them about was, he replied that it was in the river.

Police alerted to Google account

Alexandra Wilson, prosecuting, told the court that in May last year Welsh police were alerted by the National Crime Agency to a Google account linked to Smith which had uploaded indecent images of children. She said the online activity was connected to a Motorola phone but the defendant had not told the police about any such device.

The court heard that on May 7 officers went to the defendant's home and during the visit they spotted an Android charging cable on the sofa - the officers asked what the cable was for, and Smith produced a number of devices none of which fitted the charger. The prosecutor said when Smith was asked directly where the Motorola identified by the NCA was, he replied: "It's in the Cleddau".

Neighbour unaware of wi-fi use

The court heard that Smith told police he had no wi-fi at his home but when officers checked his devices they found they were all connected to an EE router, and that the router belonged to a neighbour. Checks were carried out and it emerged the neighbour - who has learning difficulties - had no idea that Smith was using his wi-fi, and had been doing so for almost a year.

Officers seized Smith's mobile phone and two laptops which the defendant had not declared, and when the devices were checked police found child sex abuse images on one of the computers in an album called "Nudity". It also emerged that Smith had downloaded and then deleted the social media app Tumblr. The defendant subsequently answered "no comment" to all questions asked in interview.

Sentencing and background

David Leonard Smith, of Stratford Road, Milford Haven, had previously pleaded guilty to four counts of breaching a sexual harm prevention order, possession of indecent images of Category C, and obtaining electronic communication services without payment - using the neighbour's internet - when he appeared in the dock for sentencing. He has four previous convictions for 16 offences.

In 2016 Smith was given a suspended sentence for possession and distribution of indecent images, and possession of extreme pornography. In 2018 he was sentenced to 16 months in prison for possession and distribution of indecent images and breaching a sexual harm prevention order.

Joseph Hocquard, for Smith, said the defendant had shown an ability to stay out of trouble "when he puts his mind to it" and said he had stable accommodation. He said his client knows his actions were wrong, and said he had "expressed some remorse".

Judge Huw Rees told the defendant he would have thought that at the age of 68 "the time for your offending had gone", and he said the defendant was "getting too old to risk going to prison".

Smith was sentenced to 16 months in prison suspended for two years, and was ordered to complete a probation requirement. The defendant will be a registered sex offender for 10 years, and was made subject to a sexual harm prevention order for the same length of time.