Richard Gadd's new BBC drama 'Half Man' has been described as a 'brutal misfire' by critics, despite its ambitious attempt to explore male trauma. The series, conceived before his hit 'Baby Reindeer', follows two men, Niall and Ruben, across 30 years as their toxic relationship unfolds.
The story begins in a dark barn with the two men circling each other, then flashes back to their teenage years. Niall, played by Jamie Bell, is a gentle bookish boy who suffers horrific bullying. His life changes when Ruben (Stuart Campbell), the son of his mother's partner, moves in after being released from a young offenders' institute.
Ruben quickly dominates Niall's life, sorting out his bullies but exacting a heavy price. The drama unflinchingly examines how hurt people hurt others, with Ruben's backstory revealing a cycle of terror and violence. It questions when men must take responsibility for their actions, asking whether there is a point where violence can be stopped.
While praised for its bravery and performances, particularly from Jamie Bell, the series has been criticised for underwritten female characters and a questionable final act. The Guardian called it 'bleak and brilliant' but noted these weak spots. Overall, 'Half Man' is a harrowing watch that leaves viewers questioning masculinity and accountability.
