A new streaming arrival on Netflix UK is causing a significant stir, with viewers delivering a sharply divided verdict on a psychological thriller starring a beloved actor from Downton Abbey.
A Familiar Face in a Tense New Role
The drama in question is Captivated, which also goes by the title Too Good To Be True. Originally airing on Channel 5 in 2024, the series has found a fresh and sizable audience after being added to the Netflix UK library, where it has swiftly climbed to third place on the platform's coveted Top 10 chart.
The plot follows Rachel Connor, a single mother working as a cleaner, whose life takes an unexpected turn when a wealthy businessman, Elliott Fielding, offers her a better job. As she becomes increasingly involved in his world, her initial gratitude gives way to deep-seated suspicion about his true motives.
The cast features notable British talent. Allen Leech, fondly remembered for his role as chauffeur-turned-family-member Tom Branson in the global hit Downton Abbey, takes on the part of the enigmatic Elliott. He is joined by Kara Tointon, an EastEnders legend, who portrays the central character, Rachel.
Viewer Reactions: From Scathing to Supportive
Despite its popularity on the streaming charts, the series holds a middling 5.6 out of 10 rating on IMDb, a score reflected in the polarised reviews from audiences.
A contingent of viewers has been fiercely critical, taking to review platforms to warn others away. One disgruntled fan branded it "an utter waste of time," criticising its "paper thin and entirely predictable plot" that allegedly worsens with each of its four episodes. Another echoed this, advising: "Don't waste your time like I did. I kept thinking it would get better. It absolutely does not."
Further critiques labelled the miniseries "predictable and unconvincing" and a disappointment, with one noting it started promisingly but "went downhill rapidly."
An Unexpected Defence from Some Fans
However, not all feedback has been negative. A counter-wave of viewers has emerged to defend the show, suggesting the harsh ratings may not tell the whole story. One described it as "strangely entertaining," while another reasoned it was "watchable" if not great.
A more supportive review argued the show is "not as bad as ratings suggest," calling it an easy watch with a coherent storyline. Another fan urged potential viewers to persevere, stating: "The first episode was good just persevere with it as the series does get better... Too Good To Be True is intense and thrilling to watch!!"
For those intrigued by the split opinion and the allure of a Downton Abbey star in a modern thriller, Captivated is available to stream now on Netflix and Channel 5's My5 service in the UK. Audiences in the United States can find it on BritBox.
