Cinema Classic Sails Past Critics, But Not Guardian's List
Readers of the Guardian have voiced their collective dismay after a recent feature listing the 20 best films set on boats or ships conspicuously failed to include one of Hollywood's most beloved nautical adventures. The article, published on 27 November and titled 'You’re gonna need a bigger boat', sparked a flurry of letters to the editor from baffled film enthusiasts who could not believe the omission of John Huston’s 1951 epic 'The African Queen'.
A Masterpiece Overboard
Correspondents were quick to champion the film's credentials. Andrea Morgale from Edgware, London, argued that the movie, starring Humphrey Bogart and Katharine Hepburn, is a deserving candidate for the "top echelon". She highlighted Bogart's Best Actor Oscar win for his role, the support from brilliant character actors like Robert Morley and Peter Bull, the "superbly explosive finale", and the "believable wartime love story" aboard the vessel itself.
The criticism extended beyond a single omission. Sian Mabbutt from Llandeilo, Carmarthenshire, made a sharp distinction, noting that while 'Jaws' (which ranked No. 3 on the list) is "a film with a boat in it", The African Queen is "one of the best films ever made that was actually set on a boat".
Other Notable Shipwrecks from the List
The discontent was not limited to the missing African Queen. Other readers pointed out further glaring absences from the cinematic seascape. Bill Geddes from Worthing, West Sussex, lamented, "I have a sinking feeling… No The African Queen! No Mister Roberts! No The Caine Mutiny!".
Doug Bastin from Chester acknowledged the article's stated ban on submarines, which ruled out Das Boot, but insisted that 'The Cruel Sea' "surely should be included" in any authoritative list of maritime films.
The strength of feeling underscores the enduring power and popularity of these classic films, particularly John Huston's 1951 masterpiece, and serves as a reminder that for many, some cinematic voyages are simply indispensable.
