Safeguarding minister Jess Phillips has stated that the primary screening tool used to assess domestic abuse victims' risk levels has 'obvious problems' and should be replaced. The Dash (domestic abuse, stalking, harassment and 'honour-based' violence) questionnaire has been used by police, social services and healthcare workers across the UK since 2009 to determine which victims require specialist support.
Phillips told the BBC's File on 4 that she is reviewing the entire support system for victims but acknowledged change would not happen overnight. 'My instinct is that the tool doesn't work, but until I can replace it with something that does, we have to make the very best of the system that we have,' she said. She emphasised that any risk assessment tool is 'only as good as the person who is using it' and that the grading system alone does not guarantee protection.
Academic studies have raised concerns about Dash's accuracy. A 2020 study by the London School of Economics, analysing Greater Manchester police data, found that in nearly nine out of ten repeat violence cases, victims had previously been classified as standard or medium risk. A 2022 study by Manchester and Seville Universities found that 96% of victims retrospectively judged as high risk had been previously classified as standard or medium risk.
Dr Heather Strang, director of the Jerry Lee Centre for Experimental Criminology at the University of Cambridge, told the BBC: 'When it comes to the question of the reliability of Dash as a predictive tool, there is a growing consensus that Dash does not do that job at all well.' Families of murdered women not graded as high risk are considering legal action against institutions they believe failed their loved ones.
Nour Norris, whose sister Khaola Saleem and niece Raneem Oudeh were stabbed to death in 2018, criticised the system as a 'tick-box exercise'. She said: 'Raneem was failed because her risk was downgraded to a tick box exercise... In order for us to save lives like Raneem's and many victims' as we speak today, we must evolve the system.'
The government has announced new measures to tackle 'honour-based' abuse, including statutory guidance and a legal definition. A Home Office pilot study will examine the prevalence of such crimes, alongside a community awareness campaign and enhanced training for professionals. There were 108 domestic homicides in England and Wales in the year to March 2024, according to the Office for National Statistics.