An American woman living in the UK has sparked outrage online after attempting to eat a crumpet straight from the packet, without toasting it first. Sarah, who posts under the handle The Cheeky American, shared a TikTok video in which she sampled Warburton's crumpets both toasted and untoasted, leaving British viewers aghast.
Traditionally, crumpets are toasted or grilled until golden and then slathered with butter, which melts into the signature holes. However, Sarah announced she would try one untoasted despite being advised that the correct method is to cook it. Upon tasting the raw crumpet, she grimaced and rated it just two out of ten, compared to the toasted version which she awarded a perfect score.
Viewers were quick to express their dismay. One commented: "First time in history a crumpet has been eaten untoasted." Another wrote: "The untoasted crumpet made me physically recoil." Many declared they had never seen anyone commit such a culinary faux pas.
Despite the backlash, it is worth noting that crumpets are pre-cooked during manufacture, making them safe to eat cold. However, the texture is often described as soft and doughy, and butter does not soak into the holes as effectively. For those who prefer a warm but untoasted crumpet, microwaving it for a few seconds is an alternative.
