M&S Percy Pig Taste Test: Only Four Varieties Score Perfect 10
Percy Pig Taste Test: Four Varieties Score Perfect 10

M&S Percy Pig Sweets Put to the Ultimate Taste Test

A dedicated Marks & Spencer customer has undertaken a comprehensive taste test of every single variety of the iconic Percy Pig sweets, delivering her verdict on which ones truly deserve a place in your shopping basket. Leah Watki, a lifestyle enthusiast, sampled the entire range for her YouTube subscribers, revealing that only four out of the numerous options available managed to secure a perfect score.

The History of a British Confectionery Icon

First introduced to M&S shelves back in 1992, the beloved Percy Pig sweets were surprisingly discontinued just five years later. However, they made a triumphant return in 2008 and have since grown into a cultural phenomenon, spawning a wide array of spin-offs and flavours that cater to diverse tastes. From classic gummies to innovative new creations, the Percy Pig range has expanded significantly, prompting this detailed evaluation to determine which varieties reign supreme.

Leah Watki's Detailed Ratings and Reviews

Beginning with the original Percy Pigs recipe, Leah was full of praise, awarding it a flawless 10 out of 10. "Yum. As I always say, you can never go wrong with the classic," she enthused, setting a high bar for the rest of the tasting session.

Wide Pickt banner — collaborative shopping lists app for Telegram, phone mockup with grocery list

Next up were the Squidgy Snouts, which also received top marks due to their close resemblance to the original flavour profile. Leah then moved on to the multicoloured Party Time Percy Pig gummies, which she found pleasant but not exceptional, resulting in a rating of seven out of 10.

The Reversey Percy option was met with mixed feelings. While Leah admitted they tasted "good," she stated she wouldn't purchase them again, giving them a six out of 10. Similarly, the assorted flavour Fruity Chews earned a six, with Leah noting that she liked some flavours but found them overly chewy.

Piglets, however, were an instant hit. "Why is everything mini just automatically better?" Leah mused, popping three into her mouth and awarding them a perfect 10. In contrast, the Original Veggie Percy version scored only five out of 10, with Leah commenting that while they're great for vegetarians, they were too chewy for her liking.

Percy Pig and Pals fared even worse, receiving a four out of 10. Leah explained, "I'm not a fan of cola flavoured sweets. The cola flavour just takes over the whole packet." Phizzy Pigtails, described as "very sour," scored an eight out of 10, appealing to sour candy lovers but not aligning with Leah's preference for sweeter treats.

Rounding off the taste test was You Give Me Butterflies, which Leah raved about, calling them "so good" and "so cute," earning another perfect 10.

The Top Performers and Underachievers

In summary, only four varieties achieved Leah's highest rating of 10 out of 10:

  • Original Percy Pigs
  • Piglets
  • Squidgy Snouts
  • You Give Me Butterflies

On the other hand, Percy Pig and Pals and the Original Veggie Percy were the least impressive, scoring four and five out of 10 respectively. This taste test provides a clear guide for Percy Pig enthusiasts looking to navigate the extensive range, highlighting which sweets are worth the indulgence and which might be best avoided.

As the Percy Pig legacy continues to evolve, this review offers valuable insights for both long-time fans and newcomers eager to explore one of Britain's most cherished confectionery lines. Whether you're stocking up for a party or simply treating yourself, knowing which varieties excel can make all the difference.

Pickt after-article banner — collaborative shopping lists app with family illustration