A long-forgotten 19th century church in upstate New York has undergone a remarkable transformation, emerging as a breathtaking $3 million luxury retreat complete with a dramatic timber frame interior and a unique bell tower library. The early Greek Revival structure, originally constructed in 1837 and situated on 37 acres in the foothills of the Catskill Mountains, has been painstakingly restored from an abandoned sanctuary into an expansive luxury residence.
Preserving Historic Character
At the heart of the property lies the church's original structure, where massive hand-chopped beams dating back nearly two centuries remain prominently exposed. These architectural elements create a cathedral-like space that dominates the home's interior, serving as a striking reminder of the building's religious heritage.
'The real standout is the great room, which is the church itself,' explained listing agent Annabel Taylor of Four Seasons–Sotheby's International Realty. 'Of course, all of those exposed beams provide such a "wow" factor as well.'
From Near-Demolition to Architectural Marvel
The structure ceased functioning as a church during the 1990s, falling into such severe disrepair that it nearly faced demolition. Decades later, architects Nik Vekic and Quinn Marquardt of ICDT Studio purchased the deteriorating building in 2023 for $425,000, embarking on a meticulous two-year transformation.
'When we first walked through it, we could see the original timber frame structure of the church, and we both realized the potential of that,' Vekic told Mansion Global.
The building had previously been dismantled and relocated to Gilboa, New York, by another owner who intended to convert it into a residence but never completed the vision. The current architects expanded upon this foundation, adding significant living space and modern amenities while preserving the historic character.
Architectural Highlights
The 6,242-square-foot residence now features numerous distinctive elements that blend historic preservation with contemporary luxury:
- Great Room: The cavernous former sanctuary now serves as a dramatic great room with towering ceilings, an open floor plan, central fireplace, and expansive dining area
- Bell Tower Library: The church's original bell tower has been converted into a unique library filled with bookshelves and bathed in natural light from tall windows
- Wine Room: Hidden beneath a staircase sits a temperature-controlled wine room capable of storing 600 bottles, concealed behind steel doors
- Guest Accommodations: A separate guest wing includes a bunk room with four beds, while a third-floor home office occupies the former steeple
- Luxury Kitchen: A chef's kitchen features marble countertops, with a butler's pantry equipped with a second sink and concealed refrigerator
Modern Amenities in Historic Setting
Additional design elements include a towering gas stove that rises from floor to ceiling in the great room, creating a dramatic focal point. The walk-out lower level contains a media room with wet bar and a laundry room complete with dual washer-dryer units.
'They were inspired by the structure of the church, but this is the first church transformation they have done,' Taylor noted. 'It makes for a stunning residence. They are very creative people who own a design studio.'
Natural Surroundings and Potential Uses
Beyond the walls of the former church, the property encompasses 30 acres of picturesque land featuring wooded trails, streams, waterfalls, and rock formations scattered across rolling terrain. Despite its secluded location, the home offers convenient access to nearby attractions, sitting approximately 20 minutes from the Windham Mountain Club.
Taylor suggests the property could serve multiple purposes: 'A no-brainer would be a family, but it could also go to a couple who loves to entertain.'
Notably, the town of Gilboa has no zoning restrictions, opening possibilities for hospitality businesses or property subdivision. 'With 30 acres, you could also subdivide the property,' Taylor explained, highlighting the investment potential beyond residential use.
The transformation represents a remarkable preservation success story, breathing new life into a historic structure that once faced demolition while creating a unique luxury retreat that honors its architectural heritage.
