South Tyneside Council has secured a court order against the owners of the derelict New Mill Inn in South Shields, resulting in a total financial penalty of £35,465.60. The action follows a lengthy investigation into the site, which had become a hotspot for fly-tipping and anti-social behaviour since its closure in 2024.
Magistrates' ruling and penalties
South Tyneside magistrates found Shireland Inn Ltd, the owners of the former pub, guilty of failing to comply with a Community Protection Notice. The court imposed a £22,000 fine, awarded costs of £2,671.60 and compensation of £1,994, and ordered a victim surcharge of £8,800. The total must be paid within 28 days.
In addition, a Remedial Order was issued requiring the necessary works to secure and improve the site to be completed within the same timeframe. The council will monitor the site to ensure compliance.
Background of the case
The New Mill Inn had been abandoned after shutting down in 2024. Plans were submitted to convert the pub into retail units, but no work was carried out. From April 2025, environmental enforcement officers repeatedly attempted to engage with representatives of Shireland Inn Ltd, who gave assurances that action would be taken. However, the problems persisted, and a fire caused by fly-tipped waste being set alight heightened concerns.
The council issued a Community Protection Warning and later a Community Protection Notice, but the site's condition did not improve, prompting the prosecution.
Council's stance
James Maughan, Head of Public Protection at South Tyneside Council, said: "This site had become a significant concern for the local community and a drain on taxpayers' money due to the council having to carry out works to secure it. Despite repeated attempts to engage with the owners, we were left with no alternative but to take formal enforcement action."
He added: "The significant financial penalties in this case send a clear message that property owners have a responsibility to maintain and secure their buildings and land, regardless of where they are based. We will not hesitate to take action where sites are allowed to fall into a condition that affects local communities, creates safety concerns, or places an unnecessary burden on public services."
