Josh Sargent was 12 when social media algorithms filled his feed with images of muscular influencers, leading him into a two-year immersion in the manosphere. Now 16, he is sharing his experience in a new documentary, Being a Boy, which examines the spread of harmful ideology online and its impact on young people.
Josh, from Cambridgeshire, described how his feed became dominated by a narrow standard of masculinity. 'There was this expectation being sold online that to be a real man you had to be incredibly muscular, big, and you had to be running an online business and making an insane amount of money, through very engaging, attention-grabbing content,' he told Metro.
His feed was similar to millions of others, with 'algorithms absolutely bombarding us with content surrounding a very specific standard of masculinity.' For Josh, it was 'the classic imagery of muscular men parading around Dubai in designer clothes, flanked by these beautiful women in supercars.'
A Vicious Cycle of Insecurity
The teenager had struggled with body confidence from a young age and felt isolated at primary school for not being one of the footballers. When he reached secondary school, he thought getting fit might help and sought answers online. But the more time he spent looking at this content, the worse he felt about himself.
He described a 'malicious vicious cycle' that affected how he saw himself and was encouraged to view women. 'For me, it affected how I approached relationships – as if I would only be worthy of a relationship if I matched this very narrow standard of masculinity.'
Josh spent two years in the manosphere, unaware of how influencers were making money by keeping him hooked on videos that made him feel worse about himself, while offering to sell him the solution.
Undercover Investigation Reveals Exploitation
As part of the documentary, Josh went undercover as a 15-year-old boy named 'James', whose social media feed quickly filled with courses promising to help boys become richer or more successful with women. On one course, 'James' was taught how to control girls, to play games with their feelings to keep them interested, and that he shouldn't seek consent before kissing. One coach said it doesn't matter how he treats girls; rather, he should use them to practise his dating skills. Another told him to record his interactions at school with a hidden mic so that his coach can collect data on what he is saying.
The documentary's director, Matt Botten, told Metro how disturbing it was to see boys being exploited. 'The whole thing is a massive scam. What we saw, over and over again, was boys being sold something, often without them realising it.' He added: 'It was dating courses, fitness courses, influencers saying: "I'm giving away all these clips for free on my YouTube", when they are just getting viewing hours and making money out of boys' insecurities.'
'The impact is frightening and twofold, because not only is it exploiting and exacerbating these insecurities, but it is leading some boys to think there is truth behind it – and that girls are the problem.'
Research and the Turning Point
In the documentary, Josh spoke to researcher George Mycock, who has studied how the manosphere exploits insecurities around body image and encourages boys to chase impossible extremes in the gym. George told Josh: 'The reason they push boys to chase these extremes is to make money. If you make the person that you're selling to's goal unachievable – they have to be constantly working to try and get to this perfect idea. So they have to keep buying your product, or watching your videos. And that's their goal.'
This realisation became a turning point for Josh and helped him eventually escape the manosphere. 'I realised that if I watch this content and give these influencers money, if I reach their vision of masculinity, I have no use for these influencers or their content anymore, and I would log off,' he explains.
Josh is now calling for more to be done by regulators, governments and the platforms themselves to crack down on the spread of harmful ideology. 'We cannot be expecting young people, some as young as eight years old, to be protecting themselves from this content.' He added: 'There is widespread evidence that these platforms are hijacking neural networks and trying to manufacture addiction. When it comes to a child's ability to regulate and critically think compared to the coordinated efforts of multibillion-dollar corporations, I think there is a pretty big imbalance there. And it is obvious who would win the struggle.'
The documentary also highlights that six in ten boys believed respect came from being tough, with more than a quarter believing crying made them look weak. A third of young people said they had seen content online telling boys how they should behave. The manosphere has this month been described as a public health emergency, but using terms like 'toxic masculinity' further isolates boys, pushing them deeper into an unhealthy online world, the documentary hears.
Josh noted that terms like 'chad', 'mogging' and 'looksmaxxing' create a false sense of community among young men, which then spreads into the classroom. At his school, he witnessed people talking about the 80-20 rule, a theory claiming that 80% of women are only attracted to the top 20% of men, which he now knows is 'pseudo-psychology BS'.
'This language has leaked into the mainstream. If the fact that 'looksmaxxing' was the word of the year in two separate dictionaries this year – that is tied to monetising the insecurity of young men worldwide – that doesn't scare us, I don't know what will,' Josh told Metro.
Sky Kids Investigates: Being a Boy will be available on Sky Kids and streaming service NOW on Friday 20 November.