Charlie Lamdin's BestAgent has issued a detailed statement defending its property listings and viewing charges after a week of mounting criticism from estate agents. The statement follows a series of Property Industry Eye reports examining the platform's business practices. It also comes just hours after Yopa chief executive Verona Frankish resigned from BestAgent's advisory board, citing concerns over its management.
BestAgent insists buyer and tenant enquiries remain free. It claims agents who received emails displaying charges were probably testing the system or receiving test enquiries. However, the company confirmed plans to introduce a pay-per-lead model in future.
BestAgent addresses disputed viewing charges
The controversy erupted earlier this week when Andrew Muskett, manager of David Burr's Woolpit office in Suffolk, tested BestAgent's enquiry system. Muskett said the platform requested £8 plus VAT to access an enquiry and confirm a viewing appointment. He declined to pay, and the viewing failed to proceed.
In its latest statement, BestAgent insisted: “But for now and until further notice, all buyer and tenant leads remain completely free of charge.” It added: “Any agent who has seen a buyer lead email with a price on it is most likely either testing the system themselves or receiving a test enquiry from BestAgent itself.”
The company maintained that it had always passed genuine enquiries to agents without charge. “To our knowledge, no agent has ever paid us anything for an applicant enquiry. If it has happened, it was in error and we would gladly provide a refund.”
The explanation addresses the apparent contradiction between BestAgent's free enquiry policy and the charges displayed during Muskett's test. However, it does not explain why the £8 plus VAT request appeared or why the viewing failed to proceed.
BestAgent confirms plans to charge agents
Despite insisting enquiries remain free, BestAgent made clear that it intends to charge agents for online viewing leads. Its proposed pay-per-lead model would link charges to the property's advertised price. The company argues this approach offers agents greater control over marketing costs than traditional portal subscriptions.
Telephone enquiries made directly to agents through property listings will remain free. BestAgent also plans to offer refunds for leads that prove worthless because applicants have provided misleading information. However, the company says it will not introduce charges until agents are satisfied with the quality and reliability of its enquiries.
Property listings dispute remains unresolved
BestAgent also defended its approach to displaying property information without agents supplying marketing material. The company said: “Whether or not an agent supplies marketing materials, we will be listing all publicly available data from all public sources on every listing where possible.”
The statement follows complaints from Muskett about the reproduction of his agency's photographs, floorplans and property descriptions. He said neither David Burr nor its vendors had authorised BestAgent to use the material. Lamdin previously argued that basic property information, including addresses, asking prices and energy ratings, was not protected by copyright.
However, the distinction between public property facts and copyrighted marketing material remains central to the dispute. BestAgent's latest statement does not directly address Muskett's allegations about the unauthorised reproduction of marketing content. It also leaves unanswered his claim concerning an alleged offer of £500 in lead credits linked to withdrawing a removal request.
Anonymous property comments defended
BestAgent also defended its decision to allow members of the public to comment on property listings. Agents have questioned the appearance of anonymous comments alongside homes they are marketing. The company argues that public scrutiny will encourage greater accuracy and transparency in property descriptions.
It says agents can respond to comments or suspend those they consider unduly harmful. Verified sellers will also be able to receive notifications and respond publicly or anonymously. BestAgent acknowledged weaknesses in the accuracy of some listings. However, it maintained that its platform was already among the most comprehensive available in England and Wales.
Frankish resignation adds to pressure
The statement comes on the same day that Yopa chief executive Verona Frankish resigned from BestAgent's advisory board. Frankish said recent developments had convinced her that management's approach no longer aligned with her professional values. She stated: “Innovation and disruption should never come at the expense of integrity, collaboration or professional standards.”
Her departure represents another setback for Lamdin. Frankish had joined the advisory board to support efforts to improve transparency and reduce transaction delays. BestAgent's latest statement does not directly address her resignation or the concerns she raised.
BestAgent admits platform remains under construction
BestAgent acknowledged that its marketplace remains a work in progress. The platform is already publicly accessible and includes more than 10,000 estate agency firms and 17,000 branches in its system. The company said it releases updates and new features almost daily.
It also warned: “Save for any signed agreements, everything about it is subject to change without notice.” BestAgent maintains that its objective is to shorten transaction times, reduce fall-throughs and improve transparency across the housing market.
However, several questions remain unanswered following a week of criticism. These include the use of agents' marketing material, the handling of viewing enquiries and the implications of future charges. The latest statement provides greater clarity on BestAgent's intentions. Whether it will satisfy the agents challenging its practices remains to be seen.