Derek McInnes represents the Rangers rank and file, but destiny will meet reality at the top of the marble staircase, according to Hugh Keevins. The new manager, who played for and supports the club, steps into a role that has seen nine permanent managers in 11 years, with only one trophy in his own managerial career—a League Cup win with Aberdeen a decade ago.
Weak-minded players need a strong-willed manager
Rangers, after spending £40 million on new signings, lost four of their five post-split fixtures last season and finished third in the Premiership. This poor form led to the dismissal of Danny Rohl, who was unconvincing and unloved. In contrast, Celtic, with a squad decried as the worst in years, went through three managers, lost eight league games, and still won the league under 74-year-old Martin O'Neill. Hearts finished second.
The case for and against McInnes
Every Rangers manager since Walter Smith has had to deal with crises created by Celtic. McInnes will be no different. His predecessors—English, Dutch, Belgian, Mexican, and German—failed to 'get' Govan. McInnes, however, has presence, a past with the club, and unprecedented financial backing. But when he reaches the top of the marble staircase, destiny meets reality. Destiny is a dream come true; reality is the fear of failure.
McInnes turned down Rangers in 2017 due to private concerns, but now he has a second chance. The club has spent 15 years as the definition of mediocrity, winning just three major trophies. The sale to American owners 49ers Enterprises was unimaginable for many. McInnes' arrival is seen as a reclamation of Scottish identity with the owners' permission.
Expectations and challenges
McInnes is the ninth permanent manager in 11 years and the first born in Scotland. If this appointment fails, where would Andrew Cavenagh and his business associates go? They need McInnes to succeed or they look clumsy. Fans have mixed views: one radio caller questioned the hype, noting Callum Davidson won more trophies in one season than McInnes in his career; another called him a 'good, upcoming manager'—though McInnes is 54.
Traditionalists want McInnes to restore the club's former glory with the zeal of a fan. Foreign managers failed to build rapport because they lacked the DNA. McInnes is now the representative of the rank and file. His job is to show what that status is worth on the park. Some argue that a manager with only one trophy has done well to get the job, but now he has a major platform and financial backing.
Expectation is immense. McInnes experienced being minutes away from winning the league only to fall at the final hurdle. That feeling will return in the first minute of the opening game next season. Rangers will start at Tannadice, while Celtic, as champions, host Dundee to unfurl the flag—a cycle McInnes must break. This week is about practicality after delivering obligatory platitudes.
