Wayne Rooney and Gary Neville have offered contrasting assessments of Michael Carrick's chances of landing the Manchester United job on a permanent basis. Carrick, who has been in interim charge until the end of the season, has overseen a significant improvement in form, with six wins, one draw and one defeat from eight matches in the hot seat.
Speaking on the Stick to Football podcast, Rooney said Champions League qualification should be enough to earn Carrick the role. "I think if they get Champions League football, he should get the job," Rooney said. "He puts himself right up there if they're looking for new managers. But he definitely puts himself in pole position, I think." United currently sit third in the Premier League, with five Champions League places reportedly available.
Neville, however, has urged caution, warning against a repeat of the situation that led to Ole Gunnar Solskjaer being appointed permanently after a successful interim spell in 2019. Speaking to Sky Sports, the former United right-back said the club should pursue the "best class of manager available" rather than being swayed by short-term results. He also noted that Thomas Tuchel's decision to extend his contract with England reduces the pool of elite candidates, which could indirectly aid Carrick's chances.
Carrick will have the opportunity to strengthen his case on Sunday when Manchester United host Aston Villa at Old Trafford. Villa sit below United only on goal difference, setting up a crucial encounter in the race for Champions League qualification.
