The FA Cup clash between Liverpool and Everton was ignited by a moment of major controversy involving Manchester City loanee Jack Grealish, leaving pundits and fans alike questioning the consistency of Premier League officiating.
Grealish, on loan at Everton, found himself in hot water during the first half of the fiery Merseyside derby. The England international launched into a reckless, high challenge on Liverpool's Amadou Onana, catching the midfielder well above the ankle with his studs showing.
Despite the dangerous nature of the tackle, on-field referee Andrew Madley deemed the offence only worthy of a yellow card. The decision was then reviewed by VAR official Stuart Attwell, who shockingly upheld the initial call, allowing a furious Grealish to remain on the pitch.
Pundits Unanimous in Criticism
Former Premier League referee and professional whistler Dermot Gallagher did not mince his words when analysing the incident. He stated Grealish was "extremely fortunate" to avoid a straight red card, highlighting that such challenges have been punished with dismissals throughout the season.
The sentiment was echoed across the sports media spectrum, with many experts agreeing that the application of the rules seemed to inexplicably bend for the high-profile player. The incident has once again thrown the spotlight on the perceived lack of consistency in the VAR room, fuelling the ongoing debate about its effectiveness in the English game.
Another Headache for Howard Webb
This controversial non-call is sure to land on the desk of PGMOL chief Howard Webb. Under increasing scrutiny this season, Webb faces yet another test in managing the fallout from a decision that appears to contradict the league's own directives on dangerous play.
For Everton, the reprieve was short-lived as they ultimately fell to a 2-0 defeat against their historic rivals. However, the post-match discussion was dominated not by the result, but by the tackle that could—and many argue should—have changed the entire complexion of the match.
