Carrick Told to Seize Opportunity for McTominay Return
Manchester United's interim manager Michael Carrick has received a surprising recommendation to orchestrate a sensational return for former midfielder Scott McTominay to Old Trafford. The advice comes from former United forward Giuseppe Rossi, who believes Carrick's temporary position presents a unique window to bring the Scotland international back to his boyhood club.
Interim Manager's Advantage
Carrick finds himself in temporary charge at United following Ruben Amorim's dismissal earlier this month, with the club expected to appoint a permanent manager in the summer. Despite this uncertainty surrounding the club's long-term transfer strategy, Rossi argues that Carrick should act decisively to secure McTominay's return.
"Bring back Scott McTominay!" Rossi told OLBG. "You can't get a player now and then change for a different player in the summer. It's all up to the coach. I feel that's all up in the air. You can't really go out and start buying players if you know the coaching situation yet. I always say McTominay because he would actually be a good player for Manchester United at this moment."
McTominay's Italian Success Story
The proposed move would represent a remarkable turnaround for McTominay, who left United for Napoli in a £25million transfer just over a year ago. Since moving to Italy, the midfielder has enjoyed extraordinary success, helping Napoli secure the league title last season while earning individual accolades including Serie A MVP honours and his first Ballon d'Or nomination.
This impressive form in Naples raises questions about whether McTominay would be willing to return to United, where his playing time was previously limited. The player himself has addressed the common perception that departing United players often thrive elsewhere, suggesting increased minutes at new clubs typically explains the improvement.
"It's just too easy of an excuse to say they left Man United and now they're doing well," McTominay told CBS Sports. "Obviously when players go away and they're playing more games, they're going to have an increase in confidence, they're going to feel better about themselves than when you're playing less minutes at Man United. But when you are at Man United you have to earn those minutes."
Carrick's Promising Start
The recommendation comes as Carrick enjoys a promising beginning to his second spell in temporary charge at United, having guided the team to a significant 2-0 victory over rivals Manchester City last weekend. This positive start has generated momentum as the club navigates the transitional period before appointing a permanent manager.
Rossi's suggestion highlights the complex dynamics at play during managerial transitions, where interim appointments must balance immediate needs with long-term planning. The former Italy international believes McTominay's proven quality and familiarity with United make him an ideal target during this uncertain period.
Whether Carrick will pursue this recommendation remains uncertain, as does McTominay's willingness to return after establishing himself as a key player in Napoli's successful campaign. The proposed move would nevertheless represent one of the more intriguing transfer stories of the season, reuniting a player who has flourished abroad with the club where he developed through the academy system.
