Carlton Under Fire Over Elijah Hollands' Mental Health Episode
Former Carlton great Sam Docherty has publicly criticised his old club for its handling of Elijah Hollands' mental health crisis during a match against Collingwood, an incident now at the centre of an AFL investigation. Hollands has been hospitalised days after the distressing on-field episode, with scrutiny mounting on Carlton's actions last week.
In a statement, Carlton confirmed the 23-year-old's admission to hospital, following what the club described as a 'mental health episode' during Thursday night's game at the MCG. The club emphasised the need for privacy, urging media not to speculate on Hollands' location or health details.
AFL Reviews Carlton's Internal Investigation
The episode has prompted an AFL-wide review, with league officials monitoring Carlton's internal probe into how Hollands remained on the field despite visible signs of distress. Chief executive Graham Wright acknowledged the club was aware of concerns during the match, stating their primary focus is on Hollands' wellbeing and ongoing support.
Wright highlighted that Hollands' mental challenges have been well-documented, with staff providing resources over a long period. He described Thursday night's circumstances as unprecedented and complex, underscoring the seriousness with which the club is treating the matter.
Medical Staff Actions Under Scrutiny
It has emerged that Hollands informed Carlton of his mental health struggles before the match but expressed a desire to play. He has voluntarily undergone drug testing and medical screenings, confirming his behaviour was not linked to alcohol or illicit substances.
Carlton is now reviewing the actions of its medical staff, including head doctor Matt Chamberlain and psychologist Stephen Rendall, as part of a broader timeline being compiled for the AFL. This investigation aims to detail events leading up to and during the incident.
Widespread Criticism and Calls for Accountability
The incident has drawn strong criticism across the football community, with questions raised about duty of care and the lack of intervention during the match. Sam Docherty expressed his dismay, stating Hollands was 'really let down' by Carlton and the AFL.
Docherty questioned why no one stepped in once concerns became clear, emphasising the failure of systems meant to protect players. Other figures, like former St Kilda captain Nick Riewoldt, labelled it a duty of care failure, arguing that players often do not self-select out and rely on those around them for support.
Coach Michael Voss noted Hollands was 'pretty shattered' and emotional after the game. The AFL and AFL Players Association are awaiting the outcome of Carlton's review, with potential penalties under consideration as the investigation continues.
