A New Jersey woman has been arrested after authorities allege she impersonated a licensed dentist, initiated a root canal procedure on a patient, and then abruptly ceased the treatment midway through, leaving the individual in severe pain and bleeding. Ana Amato, 49, of Old Bridge, is accused of engaging in unlawful dental practices that resulted in significant harm to a patient who sought her services through a WhatsApp group advertisement.
Details of the Alleged Dental Fraud
According to prosecutors, the patient responded to an advertisement in a WhatsApp group chat, where Amato offered dental services. He paid a $1,000 fee for a root canal and attended an appointment on September 22, 2025, at an office in South River. During the session, Amato administered an anesthetic injection and began drilling the tooth, but she allegedly halted the procedure partway through and instructed the patient to return a week later for completion.
Failed Follow-Up and Financial Dispute
Before the scheduled follow-up visit could occur, investigators report that Amato informed the patient she could not finish the root canal and provided a list of alternative local dentists. When the patient later returned to request a refund of his $300 deposit, she refused, leading to a confrontation that prompted police intervention. The patient, still bleeding and with gauze in his mouth, proceeded to police headquarters to file a formal complaint, which ultimately triggered a deeper investigation.
Police Investigation and Arrest
On February 19, 2026, South River police executed a Superior Court-authorized search warrant at Amato's business on Main Street, seizing multiple items as evidence. The investigation, initiated after officers responded to the altercation, was spearheaded by Detective Patrick Molina, with initial efforts by Sgt. Roselli and Officer Szukics highlighting discrepancies in Amato's claims.
Criminal Charges and Legal Proceedings
Ana Amato was arrested and now faces three serious criminal charges: Unlawful Practice of Dentistry, Aggravated Assault, and Financial Facilitation of Criminal Activity. Police emphasize that the case remains active and ongoing, with authorities urging community members to come forward with any additional information that could assist Detective Molina at 732-254-9002 extension 113.
Police Commentary on the Case
South River Police Chief Mark Tinitigan praised the diligent work of his officers, noting that what began as a routine dispute call unveiled a more severe public safety threat. He stated, 'What began as a routine dispute call demonstrated exactly why thorough police work matters. Sgt. Roselli and Officer Szukics recognized that something did not add up and took the extra steps necessary to protect the public.' Chief Tinitigan also commended Detective Molina for his persistence and attention to detail, which were crucial in advancing the investigation and securing the charges.
The incident underscores the dangers of unlicensed medical practices and the importance of verifying professional credentials before undergoing any medical or dental procedures. Authorities continue to investigate the full extent of Amato's activities and any potential additional victims.
