Prime Minister Keir Starmer has firmly rejected Scottish First Minister John Swinney's demand for an urgent summit to address growing constitutional tensions, marking the first major clash between the new Labour government and the Scottish administration.
In a letter seen by The Independent, Swinney had called for an immediate meeting to discuss devolution settlements and the transfer of new powers to Holyrood, framing it as a matter of "real urgency." The Scottish leader specifically requested the return of EU powers and the devolution of employment legislation.
Starmer's response, delivered through a spokesperson, was unequivocal: "The Prime Minister has said he will meet with the First Minister in due course, but the idea that it would happen this week was not agreed." The rebuff signals Starmer's intention to set his own timetable for engagement with devolved leaders.
Constitutional Showdown Looms
The exchange sets the stage for a potential constitutional showdown between Westminster and Holyrood. Swinney's letter, sent just days after Starmer entered Downing Street, emphasised the need to "build a stable, sustainable and collaborative relationship between our governments."
However, Starmer's team appears determined to avoid being rushed into negotiations, preferring to establish the new government's priorities before engaging in complex constitutional discussions.
Broader UK-Wide Approach
Instead of bilateral meetings with individual leaders, Starmer has opted for a broader approach. He is planning to host a "rural summit" and has already met with mayors from across England, indicating a preference for UK-wide forums rather than separate negotiations with devolved administrations.
This strategy suggests Starmer intends to emphasise the unity of the United Kingdom rather than treating Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland as separate entities requiring distinct negotiation processes.
The Prime Minister's spokesperson reinforced this position, stating: "We will work together to ensure the best outcomes for people across the United Kingdom, and that collaborative working will be based on the foundation of respecting the devolution settlement."
What Happens Next?
While the immediate summit has been rejected, both sides acknowledge that a meeting will eventually take place. The timing and agenda, however, remain firmly under Westminster's control.
This early exchange establishes the tone for what could become a defining relationship in Starmer's premiership, testing his ability to manage constitutional tensions while pursuing his government's domestic priorities.
