Six Traveller families have won a High Court appeal against a decision that would have prevented them from living on land they own in Newark-on-Trent, Nottinghamshire. The families, including Charlotte Smith and her five neighbours, were told by Newark and Sherwood District Council to leave the site because they lacked planning permission.
The families initially appealed to the Planning Inspectorate, which sided with the local authority. However, the High Court quashed that ruling on 16 October, agreeing with the families' lawyers that the inspectorate had failed to treat the council's lack of a five-year plan for Gypsy and Traveller sites as a significant material consideration.
Charlotte Smith, a mother of four, said the weeks leading up to the hearing were emotional. She described receiving a letter from her 10-year-old daughter addressed to Prime Minister Boris Johnson, asking: 'Can we live at Old Winthorpe Road Stable Yard? The council won't let us live there and I live in Newark.' Smith said her children were 'jumping for joy' when she returned home with the news.
The families bought the land to have a stable home after previously living on the roadside. The council argues the site is unsuitable due to flood risk. Smith emphasised that the families are 'working class people' who pay taxes and want to integrate into the community. She noted support from the Winthorpe Estate Residents' Group.
The Planning Inspectorate has 28 days to appeal the High Court decision. If it does not, the families' original appeal will be reheard. A spokesman for the inspectorate said the quality and accuracy of its decisions is very important.