Prime Video has quietly cancelled the drama It's Not Like That after just one season, despite the series holding a perfect 100% Rotten Tomatoes score. The eight-episode show, which premiered at the start of 2026, follows a newly-divorced woman and a recently widowed man as they explore the possibility of a romantic future. According to Deadline, the cancellation is somewhat surprising given the strong reviews and apparent popularity.
Strong Reviews and Early Viewership
Although Prime Video has not released specific viewership numbers, the streaming service began publishing weekly Top 10 rankings in June 2026. The first list, released on June 3, featured It's Not Like That at No. 9 on the global series chart. Deadline noted that the show seemed to be performing well, making the cancellation decision unexpected.
The series has been described by fans as a 'breath of fresh air' and an 'emotional rollercoaster.' On X (formerly Twitter), one user wrote: '@PrimeVideo what is this you are doing, cancelling #ItsNotLikeThat ??!! Great TV. Great writing! Great talent! We have loved this. Why are you doing this?! Bring it back! Bring it back!'
Fan Reactions and Cliffhanger Ending
The cancellation has left fans fuming, particularly because the season ended on a frustrating cliffhanger. In the finale, recently widowed minister Malcolm (Scott Foley) finally professes his feelings for Lori (Erinn Hayes), but it turns out to be only in his imagination. Viewers will never learn whether Malcolm truly reveals his feelings.
On Reddit, one fan commented: 'I actually found it charming and was hoping for more. It was extremely corny, though.' Another fan on IMDb reviews stated they would be 'absolutely devastated' if the show were not renewed, adding: 'I love everything about this show, and will be absolutely devastated if it's not renewed!! It was a beautiful ride through faith, family, friendship, love, relationships.'
Praise for Inclusivity and Emotional Depth
Several viewers praised the show for its wholesome content suitable for families. One viewer remarked: 'It's not overly dramatised and doesn't give you that feeling that the producers are trying too hard for ratings. Character development met with healthy emotional moments had me reflecting on my own life and really connecting with the families and their circumstances. It was a breath of fresh air in the sense that families of all ages could watch this together without having any inappropriate content to worry about.'
Another fan pleaded: 'Please renew this! This show is so raw and emotional and everything I didn't know that I needed right now. I cried, I laughed, I felt all the emotions with these 2 families.'
No Official Statement from Prime Video
The Express has contacted Prime Video for clarification on the cancellation, but no official statement has been released as of yet. The show's cancellation remains a mystery, leaving the fate of Malcolm and Lori unresolved.
