My Chemical Romance took the stage at Anfield Stadium to the strains of the Carpenters' Yesterday Once More, a syrupy but heart-rending reminder that the current tour is essentially about nostalgia: it celebrates the 20th anniversary of the release of the emo figureheads' third album, The Black Parade. The album, an hour-long concept piece about a dying cancer patient, was a band throwing everything they could think of at a record, apparently gripped by fear that the multi-platinum success of its predecessor, 2004's Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge, would prove fleeting.
A Concept Album Amped Up to 11
The album variously sounded like pop punk, Queen, Britpop, glam, heavy metal, Pink Floyd circa The Wall, and Kurt Weill—so wilfully overblown that when Liza Minnelli made a guest appearance on vocals, the listener scarcely raised an eyebrow. The end result catapulted the band to even greater fame, and its reputation has only increased. In some quarters, it is openly described as the Sgt Pepper of emo. A 2019 feature in the New York Times detected its influence not merely in subsequent emo bands, but in the work of pop and rap artists such as Juice WRLD, Lil Uzi Vert, 100 Gecs, Billie Eilish, Melanie Martinez, and Post Malone.
Happily, My Chemical Romance seem to have decided that the best way to celebrate the album's anniversary is not merely to perform it in full, but to amp things up further, as if they had concluded the original was perhaps a little too understated. The show now arrives with an entirely new concept: a storyline about a dystopian dictatorship called Draag, which comes with its own language and alphabet, designed by frontman Gerard Way. Stern-faced government officials and soldiers stalk the stage; an actor playing the country's leader sits on a throne, impassive in shades; Way sings Welcome to the Black Parade from a lectern.
Baffling Yet Entertaining Spectacle
It is not clear whether all this is intended as a comment on America's slide into authoritarianism—though there is definitely something of the ghastly obsequiousness surrounding Donald Trump in Way's description of the dictator as 'the most handsome man alive'—but it is not entirely clear what is supposed to be going on full stop. At one juncture, a mock execution by firing squad takes place in the centre of the crowd, followed by a burst of Boots Randolph's Yakety Sax, better known as the theme from The Benny Hill Show. During Mama, a man with his back on fire runs across the stage. By the time the band reach Famous Last Words, most of the set is consumed by flames. Stuff about a nuclear war flashes across the big screens, which potentially explains the flames, but does not explain why, midway through The End, Way is stabbed by a man dressed as a pierrot: he concludes the song prone on the stage, covered in blood, before the pierrot detonates a suicide vest.
It is completely baffling, but equally, it would take a monumental effort not to be entertained by the relentless bombardment of visual effects and hammy acting, and indeed the sense that My Chemical Romance themselves are abundantly aware of how preposterous it all is: Way sings the angsty ballad Cancer to a ventriloquist's puppet. Moreover, the music on The Black Parade is strong enough to withstand whatever imagery the band throws at it. No matter what is happening onstage, the actual songs cut through, whether it is the T. Rex-y glam of Teenagers, or I Don't Love You, which is essentially Coldplay's Yellow with dyed hair, piercings, and copious kohl around the eyes.
Second Set Showcases Classic Songwriting
A second set, flitting through the rest of their back catalogue, demonstrates that classic songwriting underpins their grand concepts and their ability to alchemise teen angst into high drama. Performed without costumes, actors, or special effects on a stage in the centre of the stadium, the songs are no less varied or melodically striking than those in the main event: the bratty glam of Vampire Money, Helena's angsty arena rock, Na Na Na's bold combination of thunderous punk rock and rococo Brian May-influenced soloing. For all the retrospection implicit in the event, it also sounds weirdly current, underlined by the fact that a substantial proportion of the audience are visibly too young to remember this stuff being released. Should the reconstituted My Chemical Romance choose to forge ahead rather than simply look back, one suspects they would be overjoyed.
