The BBC cooking show MasterChef has lost its sparkle, and all attempts to revive it have failed miserably, according to a senior showbiz reporter. The programme, once a staple in households across the UK, has been plagued by scandals and unsuccessful reboots since its original hosts were axed.
The Fall of Gregg Wallace and John Torode
In July 2025, hosts Gregg Wallace and John Torode were removed from the show after an investigation into Wallace's conduct. The report substantiated 45 out of 83 complaints against him, including inappropriate sexual language, unwelcome physical contact, and being in a state of undress. Torode also faced an upheld allegation of using "an extremely offensive racist term," though he claims to have no recollection of the incident.
The duo had been set to celebrate 20 years on the show. Their departure marked a turning point for MasterChef, which had previously been known for its light-hearted banter between the hosts.
Failed Attempts to Revive the Show
Since the scandal, the BBC has tried to salvage MasterChef with new presenters. Food critic Grace Dent and chef Anna Haugh took over hosting duties earlier this year. However, the first series paired Dent with Torode while the investigation was still underway, drawing viewer attention away from the contestants and onto the awkward pairing.
The delayed airing of the final series hosted by Wallace and Torode only added to the controversy. Two contestants asked the BBC to edit them out at the eleventh hour, further distracting from the competition.
MasterChef: The Professionals Also Struggles
The spin-off show MasterChef: The Professionals faced its own issues. Producers brought in Saturday Kitchen host Matt Tebbutt to support Marcus Wareing and Monica Galetti, but he was axed after just one series. Reports suggest show bosses decided the programme didn't need a third presenter, leaving Tebbutt heartbroken. Critics argue this indecision shows the BBC is scrambling to keep the show alive without a clear plan.
Meghan Markle's Controversial Appearance
Moving to the Australian version of the show, Meghan Markle made a guest appearance that embarrassed Brits. She reportedly left feeling "very frustrated" after the host mentioned her royal status, despite her team specifically asking not to use the word "royal." A source told news.com.au that the Duchess and her team were "very frustrated" by the promo wording. This incident added to the show's tarnished reputation.
A Call to End MasterChef
The show has officially lost its sparkle, according to the reporter. It has changed from a light-hearted evening wind-down to a sterile, matter-of-fact programme that makes for an uncomfortable viewing experience. The critic concludes that it is time for MasterChef to be brought to an end, suggesting a new cooking show should replace it in 2026.
