Elf's £5 main stain lip marker impressed in testing as an affordable, fuss-free alternative to Wonderskin's viral lip stain, though it falls short on pigment and longevity.
Testing Elf's budget lip stain
The budget beauty brand's makeup stains are gaining traction on TikTok. Elf's lip stain marker is available in nine shades, including black cherry, light pink, orange, and red, and has been praised for its hydrating, lightweight texture and sheer finish. The product was tested by applying it in the morning and assessing the finish, staying power, and feel on the lips throughout the day.
Unlike Wonderskin's wipe-off formula, Elf's lip stain marker does not require wiping or peeling off. The applicator has a pointed side for lining lips and a flat side for filling them in, offering precision similar to a lip liner. While the pen's precision was preferred, the pigment is not as strong as Wonderskin's, requiring a few layers to build up to desired coverage, which is enhanced with gloss and balm.
Transfer resistance and staying power
The beauty brand claims the formula is transfer-resistant with no touch-ups required. After initial application, only the slightest bit of transfer was noted on blotting, which was described as impressive overall. However, Wonderskin's formulas create a more subtle, believable stain, while Elf's can look noticeably more like a traditional lip stain.
The lip stain lasted up to five hours, through eating and drinking, before needing more definition. Whether refreshed with a pencil lip liner or layered with more stain, the formula remains comfortable and does not become dry or flaky with repeated application throughout the day.
Is Elf's lip stain worth it?
Elf's lip stain impressed for the price, but the pigment, longevity, and overlining performance are not as strong as Wonderskin's. It offers a middle ground between lip liners and lip stains, making it a good option for those wanting to try the trend without fully committing. For those who prefer a natural look, Wonderskin's is recommended.
